Originally Posted by
Scarlett Berry:
“Bear most certainly has not brought a lighter entertaining side to the house.
In fact he has done the complete opposite.
He has single handedly oppressed the hm's and brought an horrendous negative atmosphere into the house.
The guy has destroyed this years BB. Worst contestant by far of any BB/CBB.
A true horror.
I feel very sorry for Ricky having to co exist in such a close proximity to such a tormenting, goading muppet.
I respect him so much more now, knowing how much he has gone through.”
There may be a grain of truth in what you say insofaras the entertainment may not always have been of an exactly light nature and it may even have sometimes bordered on goading , harrasment bullying and victimisation, and the other housemates may in varying degrees have had to endure a grueling , stressful and tireing ordeal - but my point remains the same that given Rickys apparent innability to establish personal connections, especially with Bear forcing the other housemates to flock closer together for protection (

) there is nothing to suggest the removal of Bear would have miracuously transformed this ability to form bonds with his housemates - the assumption otherwise is a big leap and totally groundless - not that you were putting that arguement.
And even if we concede that the entertainment offered by the Bear Show may not have been textbook "light" and arguably of a questionable nature

that does not alter the general concensus backed up by the ratings that it was entertainment.
So we have the proven entertainment of Bear vs the theoretical opening up of Ricky if Bear hadnt been in the show - an opening up that is an unknown and imho doubtful.
Judgement = the ratings hit and great entertainment of the BearShow wins every time.