Originally Posted by kaycee:
“To be honest, Anton is actually a REAL judge, as he has judged many comps. However, he's a big no no for me.”
So, he's more than qualified as a dancer, has previous judging experience, would make the transistion easy (the key thing for regular Strictly viewers and the general public) but you don't want him.
Have an Anton prejudice per chance?
Originally Posted by VintageWhine:
“Yes, he's knowledgeable and can talk very sensibly when he wants to .
When he wants to...
I suspect he wouldn't gel with the other judges - so perhaps an unknown, straight-talking expert judge would be the best solution. Craig would be OK as head judge - it's only a bit of fun, after all.”
So, you suspect on something completely unfounded. He gets on famously well with all the judges, don't know why you think he wouldn't gel?

Have you got an Anton prejudice too?
Craig could still be mean, Bruno can still be mad, Darcey can still letch after each good looking man and Anton could be the entertaining, friendly judge. You know, the one who celebs could respect a lot too because he knows the show extremely well, been there done it etc.
I'd take a lot more from Anton's critiques than the others if I'm honest because he understands Strictly so well...