Originally Posted by writer_composer:
“I think everyone's forgetting the history Denise and Phil share, Phil was involved in Kevin's death (Kevin Wicks, Dean and Carly's adoptive father and arguably Denise's most deepest love) which fully explains the shock horror in Denise's face:
She's carrying the child of the man who killed her one true love.
Once again, DTC has looked at EE history and created a storyline which embellishes the longer-running relationships of the square, this time definitely not retconning. Denise and Phil's main agitation was in Christmas 2011 when Denise found out he was involved in Kevin's death (running in parallel with the Masood B&B fire) and she's hated Phil ever since, part of why she snapped at Louise earlier in the year, foreshadowing her pregnancy.
Plenty of drama and storyline potential.”
Originally Posted by londongirlGre:
“All I got from that post is that it's good that Phil is dad because they hate each other. Not a good enough reason for me.”
Just to clarify, the post I did (quoted above) was not about hate. It was responding to the fact you stated Phil's parentage didn't have drama and storyline potential.
"Soaps", as I'm sure we all know, are a colloquial term for
serial drama aka
continuing drama. In order to keep a soap running for years and develop longer term characters, like Denise, it's great to build on
history and progress early contentions between characters into larger ones or build on former personality clashes into larger ones or build on former issues into larger ones, etc etc to create
continuing drama.
- I.e. with Stacey's bipolar in 2009-2010 is progressed or furthered 6 years by pregnancy into the larger issue of post-partum psychosis.
- and in this case, the contentions stemming from Denise's 2011 revelation of Phil being involved in Kevin's death now being progressed by Denise being impregnated by Phil (her lover's killer)
Now. I'm not saying that new characters should never be developed and remain as newer characters, indeed Kush is a fantastic character - who I LOVE as well as Denise - and should have gritty material and I think everyone's completely missing the fact that Phil being the father gives Kush even more material to do! Making Kush the father would have been easy as we know (from his initial reactions in the hospital scene) that he desperately wants to be the father to Denise's child...but with Phil being the biological father, Kush will have to fight and prove to Denise and albeit Phil (when/if he finds out) that he loves the child and is the best father for the child, that he can and will protect and guard the child with his life. He will have to Prove his love for Denise and her child despite Carmel's disapproval, Phil's ego-denting which is far more dramatic than him simply being the father and choosing to accept his responsibility (which he would automatically want to do since longing to be a father again since losing Zaair to stillbirth and Arthur to Martin).
And just on a general note, in terms of dramatic effect:
She's carrying the child of the man who killed her one true love. (the killing occurring nearly 10 years ago and ending a relationship which cemented Denise as a character on the square)
has a wider effect than
she's carrying the child of her best friend's son (who she's developed feelings for over a period of weeks and been friends with for a year).
Summary: Phil being the father doesn't cut Kush out or limit his storylines, it actually opens the door to more meaty storylines for Kush to prove himself to Denise and her child