Who will be put into the boy band?
It's inevitable that a boy band will be created this year in the hope that they will take over from 1D


Who do you think will go into the group?

For me I think
Niall saxton
Ryan lawrie
Matt terry
Freddie parker
James Hughes

Well that's what I think anyway

I think some of them have a good chance of making it to the lives on their own

Of those you mentioned, based on their auditions and on video clips James and Freddie and possibly Matt all have potential to do well solo. The rest of them all might struggle as solo artists,but have something that would suit a band.

Nah they are all good as soloist couldn't see any of them in a group. You might want to read some of the other threads

You must be avoiding the spoilers is all I will say.

Most of the group will be made up of bad vocalists and if we're lucky there'll be a Gary Barlow in the mix that can actually sing.

Just by watching the boys auditions there is an inkling of who will be in a suspected new band. Some names have been mentioned previously and I reckon the YesLad boy that Simon said stood out although he didnt say who.

Any band that has fared well at live shows has been put together at boot camp/judges houses. (Jls are the only ones I can think of that havent been tampered with)

With 1D gone there is a void in the boyband market. Simon isnt daft, a new constructed boyband is on the cards.

no idea bet they make 1 though

I don't know why he hasn't promoted Union J more. Marketable and good looking lads most of whom can sing. Seems like a missed opportunity to me

It may be they didn't live up to Simon's boyband standards. Which seem to be; cute, massively hardworking, ready to do exactly what they're told, and drug-free (or at least not caught doing them).

I am doing. Something tells me that they boy band may have already been chosen

Of those listed, I could see Ryan and Matt being put into a boyband. Niall and Freddie were quite distinct, James doesn't particularly fit the boyband mould either.

I don't think Matt's nan would agree with that. She won't want him to be put in a boy band and as she thinks she's 'Mrs Cowell' she'll have a big say in it

I also think Union J's 'moment has gone'. It would be tricky to bring them back from the wilderness whereas a freshly put together boy band will be new, exciting and most importantly getting night prime time coverage on Saturday night over a few weeks.

I think Ryan and Matt would be good in a band. They're good but don't think they would stand out from the crowd alone. They look boy-band-ish to me. I could see Freddie being put in as a frontman as well but could easily be a solo act. Niall has a good, but not very strong/powerful, voice so could also be shoved into the background a band.

Don't know why but don't see James in a band at all.