Originally Posted by kitkat1971:
“Isn't it rather strange that none of them seemed concerned that their Dad had clearly hit somebody again? Would you not wonder who it was? But no, they just faff about doing a fake wedding for Alfie and Jade.
Don't get me wrong, what is happening to Jade and Alfie is dreadful, of course they'd want to do their best to comfort them and cheer then up. But they seemed utterly unconcerned that their father had beaten somebody up.
Re James, i think it has just always been this way within their memory - their Dad and James don't get on so they don't query him being absent from family events. Also, James seems like he could well be a good 10 years older than Nathan and ellie who i'd guess are both mid twenties. So he'd probably have left home for university not long after their proper memories start so he's just not been there most of the time and they're used to it that way.
It is amazing how much abuse can stay hidden within a family home, not just sexual but physical as well.
I can believe that Marnie and the others didn't/don't know though Marnie might have suspected. I'm sure she knows that James takes the blame for her acts, that it is her fault Mac thinks so little of James, but probably not what form the dislike and punishment has taken.
Re Jade not dying because it is too dark - HO do have characters die on dark storylines and of course Dawn died of Cancer many years ago so there is a precedent.
I actually think that them working with "stand Up to Cancer" might make it more likely that one of them will die as although they'll want to promote hope and the power of positive thinking, not to mention getting anything suspicious checked quickly and taking all treatment offered. I think they will also want to get across that sometimes there is nothing that can be done which is why it is so important to keep raising money so they can fund Research to find cures so that less and less people die in the future.”
Hi KitKat
That was a bit odd, they just let Mac go without questioning him at all, I know Jade and Alfie were important bearing in mind her news, but Mac's anger is surely an important problem to tackle.
You're right, I never considered the age gap and memories of the younger Nightingale's, of course, sadly abuse can be hidden, and in this case it definitely has.
Yeah, Dawn died, and Steph was terminal even if they severely messed up her death with that horrific ending.
I never thought of your 'SUtC' angle, and Jade dying to create a powerful message would work, I hope she doesn't, but it would be very brave of the show to go down that,l route.