Originally Posted by jamesp26:
“Hmmm - not quite sure i'm buying into all the praise. The cinematography of the supercars section was amazing as always, but we've seen it all before. The introduction was great (maybe a bit self indulgent - but who cares!)
The huge let down for me were the audience sections. For some reason, the 3 of them have suffered with scripting problems for a while now. It was more forced than ever here to the point where it didn't even feel like it was a show filmed in front of an audience. It felt like they had several hundred actors in the room shouting on queue. For 3 guys who are great friends and have worked for so long together, i don't understand why it seems so false.
New track is interesting and i like the american driver (although i imagine the joke might wear thin if it doesn't change week on week). I'm sure i'll watch the entire series and i imagine it will find its feet a bit more over time. However, i personally don't think this is the 5* winner everyone in the press is making it out to be.”
“Hmmm - not quite sure i'm buying into all the praise. The cinematography of the supercars section was amazing as always, but we've seen it all before. The introduction was great (maybe a bit self indulgent - but who cares!)
The huge let down for me were the audience sections. For some reason, the 3 of them have suffered with scripting problems for a while now. It was more forced than ever here to the point where it didn't even feel like it was a show filmed in front of an audience. It felt like they had several hundred actors in the room shouting on queue. For 3 guys who are great friends and have worked for so long together, i don't understand why it seems so false.
New track is interesting and i like the american driver (although i imagine the joke might wear thin if it doesn't change week on week). I'm sure i'll watch the entire series and i imagine it will find its feet a bit more over time. However, i personally don't think this is the 5* winner everyone in the press is making it out to be.”
I buy the Times on Saturdays, and the review in there gave it 2 stars out of 5 and said that it was fairly tame. The reviewer praised the production values and the rapport they have, but everything else was stale and scripted.
Given the Times review, and the underwhelming advert on TV at the moment doesn't really sell it to me. There looks to be far too much 'muscle' and not enough rolling over in Reliant Robins.




) and the new 'Stig', in so many words, was a bit meh, but I understand they can't do a lot of stuff now that the BBC has religiously copywrited, so I suppose they made the best out of a bad situation on that front.
One episode! We've had one episode! I'm sure that "rolling over in Reliant Robins" type stuff will come. They're not going to do everything in the first show. If they'd done a two-part "cocking about in modified Mini Metros travelling across a desert" skit for the launch, people would no doubt be moaning that there were no supercars and it was the end of the world. I don't doubt that the first run of 12 episodes will include everything we're used to and plenty more besides.
). I got a very similar experience from watching TG - liked parts of it, was bored by others, didn't really enjoy the studio bits.