Most scouted acts don't even get past the first producer audition they go to.

'scouted' just means a researcher contacted them, sometimes just by a tweet or youtube comment, and asked them to apply.

they do it to 1000s of acts, they send open emails to stage schools asking their students to apply, etc.

People act as if being scouted means something special and it's all a fix when it's not at all.

It's so general, you might as well also say those that auditioned after seeing the TV advert for applications were also scouted.

Not everyone, just the one's that they choose, they chose her, she was picked for this little skit.

TWEET FROM LUIS ELKES:

"Keep reading so many articles on @KirstyMMusic #XFactor audition ❌🎤 It wasn't staged! Kirsty just wanted to fight for her dream ❤️💂🏼💭"



and Kirsty herself tweeted:

"It was not staged, however I agree how its been shown looks like it was. Ill be doing a Q&A live on Facebook soon!🎵"

XF has become so overtly manipulative, that even when there might possibly be a hint of something spontaneous, no one believes it anymore.

The show that cried wolf, if you will.

I think this is all getting a little over-analysed now.

I'm out, as the Dragons say.

That's your decision, but on the previous page you may have missed where I posted how Daisy Gill has ADMITTED in youtube comments that the girl who she SPONTANEOUSLY walked into the audition room with was indeed Kirsty - if that's not proof then I don't know what is tbh.

I thought this thread would be an opportunity to engage in intellectual discussion about my argument (with evidence to back it up) but instead people have completely ignored it and are just going with what they saw on the telly and can't get past the "X Factor is staged" mindset and realise there are exceptions.

Yes i think that's what happened.

I'd be livid if i was told i was going to perform and didn't get too.

What about the girl group that she interrupted though? didnt they also have a right to be heard? they just walked out as soon as she appeared, thats the main thing that makes it look staged, no one would give up their slot when they were already standing there ready to sing.

Its all a load of poop really.

They were heard actually, they just didn't air their performance - apparently they didn't make it, which could explain why they didn't show them. The show used manipulative editing to make it look like Kirsty "stole" their slot. It's all in the edit.

Who cares?

It's not like Kirsty is going to win The X Factor. If anything, we'll probably see her on other reality TV shows in 2017. She's fame hungry and different TV producers will milk the cow dry.

I think security should have removed her till it was her turn

I'll file this alongside "proof Sharon Osbourne hasn't had plastic surgery".

At first I thought it was real, as her acting was so good, too good for a singer, but changed my mind as this is XF where fixes are well known. So I'd say it's 50/50, and time Simon told us
Last edited by Dix : 18-09-2016 at 19:11

Excellent foresight of them to use it on her from the moment she ran into the room, also managing to pick up the bloke asking her to stop with all the concern of Willy Wonka watching a boy fall into a chocolate river.