Originally Posted by Saint4805:
“Ben is technically the poorest singer to ever win the show. Even Leon could do a basic vibrato. Ben had a bit of a husky voice but that was it. He was 'looked after' in terms of song choice, staging etc.
Andrea Faustini was head and shoulders above Ben in terms of pure ability. Just check his versions of Listen, Earth Song, Oh Holy Night and Feeling Good on YT and compare it to Ben and you'll see what I mean.”
Ben Haenow could outsing Louisa, Leon, Steve, and Sam Bailey to be fair as he at least had a vocal, however limited it might've been.
However the problem with Ben was that he started off with an interesting Rock meets Soul sound in the Room Audition, then he was Pop Rock, and then he became just Pop by the time it got to the lives.
Basically Ben was not the best Rocker that they could find, but Simon definitely brought the worst elements of his vocal out with stuff like Bridge Over Troubled Water, I Will Always Love You etc.