Originally Posted by Aaron_Silver:
“As an outsider looking in, I find the extremes of this debate hilarious. I am a former viewer, who returned in March/April this year, I last watched about 10 years ago when Robert was a straight kid, Zoe Tate was the only gay in the village and Aaron had not even been dreamt of. Taking all that into consideration, I don't have the attachment to characters or the outrage of past wrongdoings, so it is difficult for me to truly decide which side to come down on, what I will say is that the truth is probably somewhere in the middle ground. I liked Karl Davies as Robert, and I like the new Robert but lets be honest, he was employed as eye-candy and not for acting talent, although I do believe he is improving on that front. Aaron is okay when he's not blubbing in every second scene. Robert being gay? I don't know really, I just don't know if it really fits? But being able to watch, and read the comments here from a neutral point of view is very interesting, they certainly polarise opinion that's for sure.”
Excellent post Aaron and I think the actors would be delighted to hear how polarising the characters are
There is nothing worse than a character that doesn't foster any feeling other than utter disinterest in the viewer.
At least love or hate means that people are interested either way