Originally Posted by RealityRocks:
“No eleventh hour settlement I am afraid! The entire hearing went ahead, Thursday to this morning. I prepared opening arguments, cross examined the witnesses for the respondent (and was cross examined myself) and presented a closing speech. I did it all in my own (with the support of my family at home, of course) and I'm not going to play it down, it was terrifying. There were a few tears in the car early on!
But as the hours passed it became easier as I learned the process and the judge praised me as an intelligent and articulate individual. I'm proud of myself, even if that's the only thing I take away from this horrible experience! But crucially, I'd do it again.
Basically the judge has said there's so much to consider in terms of evidence and my complaint being multiple in points, so they (two legal counsel and he) will reconvene at a later date and I will find out within 5 weeks by letter. It's not too nerve wracking, life goes on, I have so much happening I'm not focussing on it.
Maybe I am naive but I was shocked at how my manager and her manager lied on oath. He even smiled and looked right at me as he lied. But I know I told the truth and that's all that matters to me, that I got though it and I stayed dignified. The judge really understood my complaint and hopefully could see the lies I was exposing. My whole character was criticised by their barrister- thst at a vulnerable time I was overly sensitive to my managers 'repeated offers of help' and I misunderstood her wording and intentions. All I know is that's not true, she was absolutely spiteful to me and she damaged my health with the worry. If she feels a fraction of that now, even if I lose, then at the very least she might not treat anyone else the way she treated me.”
Well I hope everything works out for you OP.
I mean, without hearing both sides of the story it's impossible for anyone here to make a proper judgement. But in all my times in HR I have never heard of any case like the one you are describing. When we go to tribunal it's either because 1 - The employee is clearly in the wrong and it's a matter of honour, 2 - The amount of money is huge and it's worth fighting or 3 - We are worried that settling the case might create a precedent that would lead us open to more employees suing us in the future.
The idea that you would take a woman who has concerns about her treatment during maternity to tribunal is beyond ridiculous. Given the sums you are talking about it's nothing but lose - lose for the company (assuming what you said is right). I can only assume that someone has lied to such an extent that management feels confident pursuing it.
If what you have said is right and the court finds in your favour (which is 99.9% likely given the facts you presented) then they are going to be facing a serious bill.