Originally Posted by GabeRich:
“I tend to agree that Tess had an off night last night, and she has annoyed be a lot this series by constantly arguing with Craig over his remarks, even more so than she used to in previous series. However last night was an aberration to a degree with the missing Brendan and Laura having to take a bye. They were obviously scrambling to fill the time her dance and VT would have taken. She is much better than Bruce though, so that's a silver lining and I love Claudia, she is so funny and always makes me laugh.
However having been a fan of DWTS and Strictly for many years there is a glaring difference in the shows hosts. Tom Bergeron over on DWTS is smooth, funny, warm and gets on with the judges while still able to defend a contestant politely if need be. He is the epitome of a good host. Tess in contrast is loud, defends the contestants like she is defending her best friend and constantly does the 'they are on their feet' and the ever annoying 'look, look, take it all in' as if the contestants have suddenly gone blind and can't see the audience on their feet. It probably doesn't help that she has the producers muttering in her ear all the time which might distract her. When it comes down to it she simply might not have the experience or the temperament to be a good host for such a big, constantly changing show like this. Bergeron is 61 and has been in the business all his adult life. Maybe they need someone older, calmer and more in control to be the front host on the show.”
Well said, agree with all your points.
I am, by the way, not really criticising either Tess or Claudia but both of them are hosting SCD because of Bruce's retirement, not because they were picked as the outstanding frontrunners for the job of running the UK's top entertainment show. Jay Hunt made a huge blunder in getting rid of Arlene which went beyond the aberration that was the woeful Alesha Dixon. It meant that when Bruce left, the BBC would have had to have huge guts to change the surviving female hosts.
Tess had served a lot of years in a role that must have been far from easy and where she had performed with skill and good humour. This absolutely did not mean she was suitable for the No 1 slot, but the Beeb didn't know what to do. And then there was Claudia and a huge clamour from the PC brigade to appoint two women and so the die was cast.
Tess is a glamorous, competent No. 2. Claudia has more talent, but her milieu is small, intimate groups. not fronting a big show with a wooden No. 1.