• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Soaps
So according to Corrie...
<<
<
2 of 2
>>
>
Eurostar
26-10-2016
Originally Posted by Janet43:
“Gail did arrange for him to see a counsellor, but he wasn't interested, although Gail thought he'd had a useful session.

They couldn't just call out an ambulance and get him sectioned. It doesn't work that way.

If they'd call the police, David would have been all sweetness and light and there would seem to b no reason for the police being called. The family didn't know he had a car full of petrol cans.”

Gail, Nick and Sarah knew of his plot to murder Clayton and die in the process. It's unlikely that police would charge a clearly mentally unstable man with planning a murder / suicide.....more probable they would be sympathetic and refer him for psychiatric help (the scriptwriters have been using David's mental illness for 'entertainment' purposes for years though).
Mark_Stewart1
26-10-2016
Originally Posted by notdebbiedingle:
“Knowing Gail she'd probably marry him!!! ”

Can't stand Phelan but even I wouldn't wish Weatherfield's Black Widow on him .


Maybe Corrie can do a Home & Away and have David seeing Kylie's face in the fridge, he'll go round the bend and they can have him sectioned that way.
LHolmes
27-10-2016
I have to admit I don't remember Callum trying to rape Sarah (as was referred to last week) at all. I thought he was just going to beat her. Still, I accept that Kylie was helping Sarah, but Tony being posthumously blamed for Callum's death is a new low, and David set out to cause destruction where it wasn’t needed last week.

The Platts are in a weird place at the moment and TPTB do need to be careful with them. The whole imprisonment of David/David's revenge line was ridiculous.

Originally Posted by Ten_Ben:
“It happens all the time. It's no different to EastEnders with Jane and Ian covering for Bobby and talking Sharon/Phil etc into keeping quiet. ”

True but at least Bobby got found out in the end. OK the rest didn't but the truth half came out. I can buy some sort of misguided 'he's just a kid' element being at play there (Bobby didn't even know he'd killed Lucy at first after all) but David's a grown man. I think most are agreed the Beales have come out of that storyline damaged as well (I've sort of made my peace with them but still hate the fact they'll never be what they were before it).
Janet43
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by Eurostar:
“Gail, Nick and Sarah knew of his plot to murder Clayton and die in the process. It's unlikely that police would charge a clearly mentally unstable man with planning a murder / suicide.....more probable they would be sympathetic and refer him for psychiatric help (the scriptwriters have been using David's mental illness for 'entertainment' purposes for years though).”

A GP referral is usually needed before someone can see a psychiatrist unless the person is having an episode where someone like the police are called. And we all know how charming David can be if he wants to be, so I doubt a GP would refer him or the police regard him as an emergency.

And where I live, you're lucky if you can get an appointment in less than about a year unless it's an emergency, which needs someone like the police to be called .........
Eurostar
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by Janet43:
“A GP referral is usually needed before someone can see a psychiatrist unless the person is having an episode where someone like the police are called. And we all know how charming David can be if he wants to be, so I doubt a GP would refer him or the police regard him as an emergency.

And where I live, you're lucky if you can get an appointment in less than about a year unless it's an emergency, which needs someone like the police to be called .........”

If the police or a GP or the police needed persuading, all they would have to do would be show them David's suicide bomber video (and explain he had a history of mental illness even before Kylie's death).

The most extraordinary thing is the Platts are prepared to live with such a loose cannon. He's responsible for Nick's brain injury and Anna's injuries : how do they know he won't go on a killing spree, wipe out the entire family and then kill himself?
Chihiro77
27-10-2016
Not every crime gets reported in real life and not every reported crime is solved.

People are acting like this is a new thing for soaps but it's happened forever, if everyone paid the price there would be no characters left and if every soap was realistic it would be boring.
Eurostar
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by Chihiro77:
“Not every crime gets reported in real life and not every reported crime is solved.

People are acting like this is a new thing for soaps but it's happened forever, if everyone paid the price there would be no characters left and if every soap was realistic it would be boring.”

If it was a one off, I would agree with you but David and Sarah covered up a murder and there were no consequences and now this case (I don't think David was reported to the police for trying to kill Nick either and leaving him brain damaged). It's sending out a very dangerous message too : if a family member commits a serious crime, you don't report them and do everything in your power to help cover it up.
Louise_Hart
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by danyell:
“How do you know Clayton hasn't felt guilty? We never see him to know.”

We saw it when David was looking on social media, He didn't give a Sh*t, he just cared about getting off thats all, He would have pleaded guilty if he felt guilty, use your loaf!
danyell
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by Louise_Hart:
“We saw it when David was looking on social media, He didn't give a Sh*t, he just cared about getting off thats all, He would have pleaded guilty if he felt guilty, use your loaf!”

He just wants to get off. So of course he will plead not guilty. Especially with low life Macca in his ear telling him he should get off as he's a kid.
Ten_Ben
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by Eurostar:
“If it was a one off, I would agree with you but David and Sarah covered up a murder and there were no consequences and now this case (I don't think David was reported to the police for trying to kill Nick either and leaving him brain damaged). It's sending out a very dangerous message too : if a family member commits a serious crime, you don't report them and do everything in your power to help cover it up.”

How could there be consequences? The only people who know the truth are David, Sarah, Kylie and Todd. Everyone else thinks it was Tony. How would the truth come out? Neither Sarah or David are likely to report it, are they? Over to Todd, then..... but why would he, as things stand currently?
Louise_Hart
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by danyell:
“He just wants to get off. So of course he will plead not guilty. Especially with low life Macca in his ear telling him he should get off as he's a kid.”

You've just answered your own question
Eurostar
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by Ten_Ben:
“How could there be consequences? The only people who know the truth are David, Sarah, Kylie and Todd. Everyone else thinks it was Tony. How would the truth come out? Neither Sarah or David are likely to report it, are they? Over to Todd, then..... but why would he, as things stand currently?”

What they should have done the night of Callum's killing was ring the police and infom them what happened. Not notifying them and burying him under the annex was not only wrong and immoral but quite grotesque. As a family, they are acting like a bunch of bandits who are answerable only to each other not to society.
Janet43
27-10-2016
Originally Posted by Eurostar:
“What they should have done the night of Callum's killing was ring the police and infom them what happened. Not notifying them and burying him under the annex was not only wrong and immoral but quite grotesque. As a family, they are acting like a bunch of bandits who are answerable only to each other not to society.”

Yes, they should have, but they didn't and it's all gone wrong since then.
Cool_mate
31-10-2016
Originally Posted by callumfreeman:
“If you have kids, it is okay for your crimes to be covered up.

Or don't report them as the guilty person has "suffered" enough, and there would be no point in reporting them.

Good advice from the show, if I witness a crime happening I shall lie to the police, as the guilty party being arrested won't change anything.

If that is the case, why should Clayton be sent down? For all we know he may have felt guilt for what he did, so surely (by Corrie's logic) that is enough for him to be let off?”

his head is all over the place....his (sexy) wife was just stabbed to death...

I'd b exactly the same as him. i wanted David to kill Clayton too. Missed opportunity that. Not just corrie tho, its the same IRL, why should the evil bastard who killed a innocent person go to prison? they should get a death sentence!

prison is not good enough for a scum like Clayton. he stabs a innocent person, goes to prison, comes out and guess what? he'd do it again, he should of been murdered by David!

ppl like the character Clayton don't feel guilt! they're just evil bastards. all they care about is getting away with it!

sorry if this seemed like a rant....just speaking my mind
<<
<
2 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map