We saw last week Sam was in the bottom 3, and I wouldn't say she was any better this week. Emily also had her poorest week this week, could Simon's girls be against each other tomorrow?

Watch last week back and you'll find that Sam technically sounded alot better this week than last week.

However Samantha could face the bottom two with Emily because Emily was so bad, and she didn't even have a Disco song to sing, although Emily could always hope that Ryan's vote is really bad.

They both should be in the bottom 2. I have no idea why Simon would want them both to sing dirges on disco night. It made no sense. Both lacklustre, slow and dull.

I hope so just to teach Simon's ego a lesson, he was very arrogant tonight after both his acts got criticized.

Yeah Simon wants everyone to listen to his criticism but he is the worst at accepting critique for his acts.

They were the worse tonight so its possible... But again... I doubt Simon will let that happen... Anyways, both boring on F****g Disco Night, common cant they stop being boring?

Both deserve to be in the Bottom 2, but we all know poor Saara will be there when she easily was one of the best IMO.

Sam and Emily were beyond boring tonight.

I think Sam should really be in the bottom 2, she was dreadful, yet again. How many chances is she going to get? I am sorry but she does not have a career in music unless she is one part of a girl group where all she has to do is dance and not do any singing.

If Emily is in the Bottom 2 then the show is rigged. She had by far the best performance last night.

Dont be ridiculous.

Has Emily ever been on first?

I really like Emily, along with Saara she is my favourite act in the competition, but I thought she was really poor last night, I'd say she gave the worst performance, apart from Honey G. I don't want her to go home but I think Simon's song choice has really put her at risk.

Fingers crossed they both are, both underwhelming boring performances.

Now this answers my question from another thread - you are taking the mick. Even if you like Emily and I don't actually mind her, there is no way you could say she was the best last night. Her performance was abysmal - even 3 out of the 4 judges criticised her, in a year when very little criticism is being dished out.

I think it's possible. I wouldn't put Sam in the bottom personally, it was quite dull but her voice wasn't as bad as it has been in some previous weeks, but I'd say she's pretty much a cert. I'm inclined to say Emily as the other because it was just horrendous. I don't usually like her, but other weeks I can see how others would like her, but this time definitely not. Ryan is improving a tad and his little fanbase will know the importance of voting for him as much as possible because he's been in the bottom so many times. I'd love Ryan and Emily to fight it out in the bottom 2.

Neither of them should have got to the lives. Emily could have scraped through but there are far better singers who were dumped at JH because they didn't fit the bill looks wise.

I don't think so. Colour me surprised!

Of the legitimate contestants, I think they were the weakest last night. I would have liked to see Emily sing something upbeat like Amii Stewart's "Knock on Wood". I don't know about Sam, they seem to be struggling to find the right song for her still.