In terms of purely singing a song well, he beat her. He's not very interesting and she's got a lot more potential vocally but he used what he has better in that performance unfortunately. You're right, she was off key on Saturday and in the sing off. She needs to work on her intonation. Really sad because she's only 17 and she's got potential. I just think she wasn't ready for the show.

Even the order of elimination is easy to predict. Saara will blow Ryan away in next week's sing off. Then she herself will go leaving each judge with one act. Next will be Emily and then we have the final.

BIB, it's alot bigger than you realise.

If this show really cared about any of it's Rock singers then they'd be able to beat really rubbish acts while singing Rock Music, which over the years they've lost to some shocking people on this show, Sam losing to nearly all of these people is just another case of being a victim of being a Rock singer.

The Rock acts very rarely ever get late time slots, they rarely ever get a Rock song to sing unless it's Queen or U2 because that's all Simon's knowledge of Rock Music dates back to, and they have to work twice as hard to get anywhere with the production or the public.

Even Indie and Folk singers get it easier on this show and that's saying something.