I feel like she meant to save Sam and vote off Ryan but she got muddled up !
Did Sharon save the wrong person ???
1 of 2
She was told to save Sam initially and then change her mind to Ryan as the show loves a big scandal.
No. she knew what the consequences would be. She merely didn't want to get booed for kicking someone out directly
Originally Posted by troy4783:
“I feel like she meant to save Sam and vote off Ryan but she got muddled up !”
“I feel like she meant to save Sam and vote off Ryan but she got muddled up !”
Totally pathetic, it was time for Ryan to go, 4th time in bottom 2 but the first for Sam, outrageous!
Originally Posted by Darcyprincess:
“Totally pathetic, it was time for Ryan to go, 4th time in bottom 2 but the first for Sam, outrageous!”
“Totally pathetic, it was time for Ryan to go, 4th time in bottom 2 but the first for Sam, outrageous!”
Technically he's never been in the bottom two before.
Originally Posted by mmpfb:
“Technically he's never been in the bottom two before.”
“Technically he's never been in the bottom two before.”
3 times in bottom 3 and then tonight in bottom 2! So technically he should have gone in my book !
Originally Posted by troy4783:
“I feel like she meant to save Sam and vote off Ryan but she got muddled up !”
“I feel like she meant to save Sam and vote off Ryan but she got muddled up !”
No, they just love the controversy and the producers think any news is good news even if its controversial! I'm so used to their rubbish now and Sam was one of my favourites but Simon dug her grave by giving her shite songs. Sam is 17 years old and he gives her a Gloria Gaynor song for Disco week. She should have had a more up tempo dancing song and she might not have been in the bottom 2! Sam had so much potential and Simon ruined it for her!
Originally Posted by Darcyprincess:
“3 times in bottom 3 and then tonight in bottom 2! So technically he should have gone in my book !”
“3 times in bottom 3 and then tonight in bottom 2! So technically he should have gone in my book !”
& mine surely next week he's going if he lands in the bottom 2 again cos after next week we will be in the Quarter finals and I cant see him getting there, I'm sure Honey G will smash the vote again with the theme securing she remains
Originally Posted by chloeb:
“She said the wrong name IMO ...not the 1st time she's been addled”
“She said the wrong name IMO ...not the 1st time she's been addled”
The minute the final two were announced I'd have put money on Ryan being saved either by the judges or deadlock because the producers still want the Ryan v Emily sing off (next week is my bet)
Because of this imo Sharon may have looked as though she deviated from the plan but in reality she did exactly what she was supposed to!
Originally Posted by Darcyprincess:
“3 times in bottom 3 and then tonight in bottom 2! So technically he should have gone in my book !”
“3 times in bottom 3 and then tonight in bottom 2! So technically he should have gone in my book !”
Well maybe
I can only speak for myself though and be thankful I'll never have to hear Sam honking down my television again.They were both pretty much as bad as each other in the sing off - both awful. Sam was consistently flat throughout, Ryan was all over the place. But when it comes down to it I find Ryan's shortcomings far less aggravating than Sam's so personally I'm pleased with Sharon's lack of competence in this instance.
Emily will be sabotaged next week by Simon to ensure the Emily v Ryan sing off.
Sharon does get mixed up with names but she's probably been told to stir it up to be honest. I've watched this show for years and i could have told you before Olly's performance what was going to happen! They love it - Lucie Jones v Jedward, Laura White etc.
I think it's obvious though either is not going to win the competition, and whilst i disagree with the result i do think if you do poll the least of all those people in public votes then you deserve to go. Ryan is SO hard to get rid of. Everyone on the tour is a winner anyway in my eyes making £50-100k, her rock voice wasn't ever going to appeal to everyone unlike Emily who is more mainstream. Simon gave her bad mentoring too in my opinion. Nicole has led the narrative of Sam failing too which hasn't helped...
Sharon does get mixed up with names but she's probably been told to stir it up to be honest. I've watched this show for years and i could have told you before Olly's performance what was going to happen! They love it - Lucie Jones v Jedward, Laura White etc.
I think it's obvious though either is not going to win the competition, and whilst i disagree with the result i do think if you do poll the least of all those people in public votes then you deserve to go. Ryan is SO hard to get rid of. Everyone on the tour is a winner anyway in my eyes making £50-100k, her rock voice wasn't ever going to appeal to everyone unlike Emily who is more mainstream. Simon gave her bad mentoring too in my opinion. Nicole has led the narrative of Sam failing too which hasn't helped...
Originally Posted by blueface2222:
“Emily will be sabotaged next week by Simon to ensure the Emily v Ryan sing off.
Sharon does get mixed up with names but she's probably been told to stir it up to be honest. I've watched this show for years and i could have told you before Olly's performance what was going to happen! They love it - Lucie Jones v Jedward, Laura White etc.
I think it's obvious though either is not going to win the competition, and whilst i disagree with the result i do think if you do poll the least of all those people in public votes then you deserve to go. Ryan is SO hard to get rid of. Everyone on the tour is a winner anyway in my eyes making £50-100k, her rock voice wasn't ever going to appeal to everyone unlike Emily who is more mainstream. Simon gave her bad mentoring too in my opinion. Nicole has led the narrative of Sam failing too which hasn't helped...”
“Emily will be sabotaged next week by Simon to ensure the Emily v Ryan sing off.
Sharon does get mixed up with names but she's probably been told to stir it up to be honest. I've watched this show for years and i could have told you before Olly's performance what was going to happen! They love it - Lucie Jones v Jedward, Laura White etc.
I think it's obvious though either is not going to win the competition, and whilst i disagree with the result i do think if you do poll the least of all those people in public votes then you deserve to go. Ryan is SO hard to get rid of. Everyone on the tour is a winner anyway in my eyes making £50-100k, her rock voice wasn't ever going to appeal to everyone unlike Emily who is more mainstream. Simon gave her bad mentoring too in my opinion. Nicole has led the narrative of Sam failing too which hasn't helped...”
Not so sure that Simon will sabotage Emily next week but I agree with you 100% on everything else you have said. I think Emily has always been Simons favourite and never gave enough time to both Sam and Gifty. Simon was such a bad mentor to Sam and like you say Nicole dug Sams grave with her negative critique which I'm sure was to keep Ryan in!
Originally Posted by troy4783:
“I feel like she meant to save Sam and vote off Ryan but she got muddled up !”
“I feel like she meant to save Sam and vote off Ryan but she got muddled up !”
Looks like it was either scripted and it was meant to happen like that for drama or someone in her earpiece told her to say Sam. Its obvious the show is fake so I don't take anything that happens on the x factor at face value, especially after that ridiculous week when the wheel fell on fright night just before Halloween and then they embarrassingly tried to pretend it was just pure chance and actually thought people would believe it. An honest mistake from sharon is the least likely option.
Originally Posted by blueface2222:
“Emily will be sabotaged next week by Simon to ensure the Emily v Ryan sing off.
Sharon does get mixed up with names but she's probably been told to stir it up to be honest. I've watched this show for years and i could have told you before Olly's performance what was going to happen! They love it - Lucie Jones v Jedward, Laura White etc.
I think it's obvious though either is not going to win the competition, and whilst i disagree with the result i do think if you do poll the least of all those people in public votes then you deserve to go. Ryan is SO hard to get rid of. Everyone on the tour is a winner anyway in my eyes making £50-100k, her rock voice wasn't ever going to appeal to everyone unlike Emily who is more mainstream. Simon gave her bad mentoring too in my opinion. Nicole has led the narrative of Sam failing too which hasn't helped...”
“Emily will be sabotaged next week by Simon to ensure the Emily v Ryan sing off.
Sharon does get mixed up with names but she's probably been told to stir it up to be honest. I've watched this show for years and i could have told you before Olly's performance what was going to happen! They love it - Lucie Jones v Jedward, Laura White etc.
I think it's obvious though either is not going to win the competition, and whilst i disagree with the result i do think if you do poll the least of all those people in public votes then you deserve to go. Ryan is SO hard to get rid of. Everyone on the tour is a winner anyway in my eyes making £50-100k, her rock voice wasn't ever going to appeal to everyone unlike Emily who is more mainstream. Simon gave her bad mentoring too in my opinion. Nicole has led the narrative of Sam failing too which hasn't helped...”
If Emily is not in the sing off, will you admit that you were wrong?
Originally Posted by Darcyprincess:
“ Sam is 17 years old and he gives her a Gloria Gaynor song for Disco week. She should have had a more up tempo dancing song and she might not have been in the bottom 2!”
“ Sam is 17 years old and he gives her a Gloria Gaynor song for Disco week. She should have had a more up tempo dancing song and she might not have been in the bottom 2!”
To be fair you can't get a much more up tempo dancing song than she was given. It was the terrible arrangement that was at fault.
Something about Sharon's mannerisms just let you know she was gonna take it to deadlock, regardless of what she actually felt inside.
Originally Posted by Virtuoso:
“If Emily is not in the sing off, will you admit that you were wrong?”
“If Emily is not in the sing off, will you admit that you were wrong?”
If Emily doesn't go into the bottom two after delivering that horror show this week then it does make you wonder what will send her into a bottom two.
Although I thought Sam was better in the sing off, in a way I'm glad Ryan got saved over Sam but only because it was a knock to the massive ego that was Simon. Simon was so arrogant last night.
Lol what was with Simons introduction of his own act for the sing off like he went 'ok it's Sam' I was literally like is that it? Something must've happened behind scenes because she literally got thrown under the bus by her own mentor! He usually introduces his acts with a bit of enthusiasm!!!
Originally Posted by Darcyprincess:
“No, they just love the controversy and the producers think any news is good news even if its controversial! I'm so used to their rubbish now and Sam was one of my favourites but Simon dug her grave by giving her shite songs. Sam is 17 years old and he gives her a Gloria Gaynor song for Disco week. She should have had a more up tempo dancing song and she might not have been in the bottom 2! Sam had so much potential and Simon ruined it for her!”
“No, they just love the controversy and the producers think any news is good news even if its controversial! I'm so used to their rubbish now and Sam was one of my favourites but Simon dug her grave by giving her shite songs. Sam is 17 years old and he gives her a Gloria Gaynor song for Disco week. She should have had a more up tempo dancing song and she might not have been in the bottom 2! Sam had so much potential and Simon ruined it for her!”
Sam has never performed well on any of the live shows. Her voice isn't strong enough. Ryan also nailed the Oasis song to perfection in the sing off. It should have been a no brainer who to send home tonight, and they got it right in the end.
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Lol what was with Simons introduction of his own act for the sing off like he went 'ok it's Sam' I was literally like is that it? Something must've happened behind scenes because she literally got thrown under the bus by her own mentor! He usually introduces his acts with a bit of enthusiasm!!!”
“Lol what was with Simons introduction of his own act for the sing off like he went 'ok it's Sam' I was literally like is that it? Something must've happened behind scenes because she literally got thrown under the bus by her own mentor! He usually introduces his acts with a bit of enthusiasm!!!”
I think they were running a little late so they had to get a move on... though, he definitely has preferred Emily for weeks now, it has to be said.
Originally Posted by mmpfb:
“Well maybe I can only speak for myself though and be thankful I'll never have to hear Sam honking down my television again.
They were both pretty much as bad as each other in the sing off - both awful. Sam was consistently flat throughout, Ryan was all over the place. But when it comes down to it I find Ryan's shortcomings far less aggravating than Sam's so personally I'm pleased with Sharon's lack of competence in this instance.”
“Well maybe
I can only speak for myself though and be thankful I'll never have to hear Sam honking down my television again.They were both pretty much as bad as each other in the sing off - both awful. Sam was consistently flat throughout, Ryan was all over the place. But when it comes down to it I find Ryan's shortcomings far less aggravating than Sam's so personally I'm pleased with Sharon's lack of competence in this instance.”
Spot on.
They want to milk "Remily" for another week I think. I wouldn't be surprised if they are pushing for a bottom 2 consisting of the couple, which is definitely a plausible outcome next weekend if Saara wipes the floor with the competition again like last week!
1 of 2
