• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • General Discussion Forums
  • Politics
Guardian: EU agrees to push UK into Hard Brexit
<<
<
19 of 32
>>
>
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by Steve_Holmes:
“As has been pointed out to you countless times, we will be able to agree our own trading deals, with our own interests uppermost - unlike the current situation - and without requiring to be a member of an undemocratic political union, an actually have to increase our national debt in order to subsidise it.”

But you've been repeatedly unable to show any specific benefit to the UK from being able to negotiate our own trad deals. No existing EU deal that can be improved on for the benefit of the UK nor any product or service we can export any more of to any country with the right deal,
Quote:
“'And the costs clearly outweigh the benefits wrt the taxpayer. Of course Businesses dealing with Europe benefit, as a result of the taxpayer paying the bill for tariff free access - yet those businesses which don't deal with the EU, ( the vast majority), get saddled with unnecessary regulations.”

Name one "unnecessary regulation"
Quote:
“There is no benefit derived by the majority of the people from membership of the EU - which is why the referendum result was what it was. other than that most important of factors, of facilitating the taking of EU holidays.
You keep bleating on asininely , about what products could be more easily exported outside of the EU - and clearly the answer is MORE of ALL of them - because the 'market outside of the EU is much greater, as is the potential for the UK to make it's own preferential trade agreements.”

How can we clearly export more of anything to anywhere than we do now? What agreement can we sign that will help us to export more of what to where?

It's that obvious yet you can't even name ONE!

Farcical.
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by mRebel:
“I just read of the increase in homelessness in Ireland, of the deaths caused by cuts to it's health service, and more hardship. Ireland is short of cash, but still, every month, it pays money, with interest, to investors who bought bonds in Ireland's banks, because the EU ordered it to.”

You sure? Or just because defaulting on your debts when you are running large deficit and are totally reliant on external funding would be catastrophic?

How much would the health service have to be cut if the Irish Govt had defaulted and couldn't borrow any more money on the international bond markets?
allaorta
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“No, it doesn't. Nor does it mean there will magically be anywhere we can export more of anything to either.”

I only asked one question and it's nice to see you've corrected your lie about abandoning.
allaorta
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“And what leads you to that conclusion? What do you think the deficit will be over the next few years and why.”

Past performance, and to answer your second question, I don't know any more than you or any more than Hammond and he doesn't know anymore than me though he may no more than you. None of us know what's going to happen next week, let alone next month or next year, especially while they're fluffing around with Brexit.
allaorta
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“You sure? Or just because defaulting on your debts when you are running large deficit and are totally reliant on external funding would be catastrophic?

How much would the health service have to be cut if the Irish Govt had defaulted and couldn't borrow any more money on the international bond markets?”

No matter how you care to dress it up, the amounts of money owed by the world's nations is a direct result of the lack of ability of the world's administrations.
JDF
24-11-2016
The problem with been in or out of eu is we are damned if we do damned if we don't.
allaorta
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by JDF:
“The problem with been in or out of eu is we are damned if we do damned if we don't.”

We're damned because, as Farage has said, this government isn't up to the job of handling Brexit.
Thor_Noggsson
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“But not by abandoning out biggest, We are exploiting developing markets quite well from within the EU anyway. No-one can tell me how leaving helps with developing markets, what can we export more of to where once outside the EU.”

I never said we should, I said we should focus more on the developing markets.
The point you seem to missing, or glossing over, is that the EU is simultaneously growing and declining and the two are interconnected. It's monetary value is growing but its share of world trade is declining. If this situation continues monetary growth will stall and slip into recession so it makes sense to loosen our links with the EU to avoid being pulled into recession.
That said, given the current legal uncertainties we are unlikely to be able loosen our ties with the EU very much and if the coice is hard brexit or no brexit we are staying because the former will never survive parliamentary scrutiny.
alan29
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by allaorta:
“We're damned because, as Farage has said, this government isn't up to the job of handling Brexit.”

I think we will eventually just fall out of the EU at the end of the two years with nothing agreed.
God knows what will happen, but its what was voted for, so it must be right no matter what. Thats democracy, innit.
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by allaorta:
“I only asked one question and it's nice to see you've corrected your lie about abandoning.”

The talk was of focus, keep up.
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by allaorta:
“Past performance, and to answer your second question, I don't know any more than you or any more than Hammond and he doesn't know anymore than me though he may no more than you. None of us know what's going to happen next week, let alone next month or next year, especially while they're fluffing around with Brexit.”

Knowledge isn't binary, it in't either we know for definite or we know nothing.

You know less than these people yet still you think they're wrong.
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by allaorta:
“No matter how you care to dress it up, the amounts of money owed by the world's nations is a direct result of the lack of ability of the world's administrations.”

Or the greed of those voting them in every time.
davor
24-11-2016
It seems like the politicians are trying so hard not to deliver Brexit. In the end, UK will remain in the EU as they don't seem to want to trigger the Article 50
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by Thor_Noggsson:
“I never said we should, I said we should focus more on the developing markets.
The point you seem to missing, or glossing over, is that the EU is simultaneously growing and declining and the two are interconnected. It's monetary value is growing but its share of world trade is declining. If this situation continues monetary growth will stall and slip into recession”

That's simply not true. Just because developing countries are developing says nothing about the state of the still growing EU and our still growing exports to it.
Quote:
“ so it makes sense to loosen our links with the EU to avoid being pulled into recession.
That said, given the current legal uncertainties we are unlikely to be able loosen our ties with the EU very much and if the coice is hard brexit or no brexit we are staying because the former will never survive parliamentary scrutiny.”

It's "loosening our ties" with our biggest export market by far that's the most likely thing that will pull us into recession.
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by davor:
“It seems like the politicians are trying so hard not to deliver Brexit. In the end, UK will remain in the EU as they don't seem to want to trigger the Article 50”

The gun is firmly pointed at the foot yet they don't want to pull the trigger, funny that.
John146
24-11-2016
[quote=andykn;84674245]The gun is firmly pointed at the foot yet they don't want to pull the trigger, funny that.[/QUOTE]

When 'we' are ready, then A50 will be activated, hopefully by March 2017...
Thor_Noggsson
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“That's simply not true. Just because developing countries are developing says nothing about the state of the still growing EU and our still growing exports to it.


It's "loosening our ties" with our biggest export market by far that's the most likely thing that will pull us into recession.”

I'm afraid it is because if the EU continues to lose market share eventually it won't be doing enough external trade to maintain growth.

The key word was loosening, though I'm not sure what you think I meant.
allaorta
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“Knowledge isn't binary, it in't either we know for definite or we know nothing.

You know less than these people yet still you think they're wrong.”

The problem with your last sentence is that we all see and experience and failures resulting from these failed and failing experts. Why else would we be in so much debt?
allaorta
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“Or the greed of those voting them in every time.”

Perhaps you could tell the people which bunch of politicians will deliver the goods.
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by allaorta:
“Perhaps you could tell the people which bunch of politicians will deliver the goods.”

Whoever you can persuade enough others to select.
allaorta
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“Whoever you can persuade enough others to select.”

OK, got it, you don't have a clue.
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by allaorta:
“The problem with your last sentence is that we all see and experience and failures resulting from these failed and failing experts. Why else would we be in so much debt?”

Because we chose that path. We want those schools and hospitals and are prepared to borrow to buy them. Just as many people will borrow to buy a house or car.
andykn
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by allaorta:
“OK, got it, you don't have a clue.”

Er, you're the one asking how democracy works. You don't like the result, you do something about it, don't just expect everyone else to want what you do.
allaorta
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by andykn:
“Or the greed of those voting them in every time.”

Originally Posted by allaorta:
“Perhaps you could tell the people which bunch of politicians will deliver the goods.”

Originally Posted by andykn:
“Er, you're the one asking how democracy works. You don't like the result, you do something about it, don't just expect everyone else to want what you do.”

There, Andykins, I've reproduced the posts that led up to your preposterous answer. I never asked how democracy works, nor did I imply anything about how democracy works.

Off for a while to do something worthwhile.
Beanybun
24-11-2016
Originally Posted by allaorta:
“The problem with your last sentence is that we all see and experience and failures resulting from these failed and failing experts. Why else would we be in so much debt?”

And your solution is what; to hand the reigns to a bunch of dustmen, bar staff and old age pensioners (no offence intended to any of the above)?

If your answer is to smash worldwide parliamentary democracy (because dictatorships, military juntas Nigel Farrage and the Donald are and will be so much batter at handling trade deficits etc after all...), it must have been a very strange question...
<<
<
19 of 32
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map