• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Strictly Come Dancing
Greg was Robbed
<<
<
4 of 5
>>
>
Venetian
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Littlegreen42:
“Such a shame this series has been ruined by the scoring. Judges obviously saving certain dancers (Ore and Joanne) mistakes mentioned yet award 10's while Greg puts everything into a dance and is only given an 8?

Claudia was awful both times, while Greg improved in the DO. Therefore he should have gone through.

But like Anita leaving before Katie last year, the Judges fix these things.”

I'll start by saying that I'm not a believer in any conspiracy theory, but if anyone is "fixing" things then surely it would be the production team, not the judges?
katmobile
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“She was and her dance was far more difficult. Greg was always going to go against the better dancers, thank goodness.”

You have got your way there is no reason to be a tit about it.
Doghouse Riley
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Venetian:
“I'll start by saying that I'm not a believer in any conspiracy theory, but if anyone is "fixing" things then surely it would be the production team, not the judges?”

The judges attempted to fix things by giving Claudia four undeserved 9s.
Whose idea that was is anyone's guess. I mean four nines including Craig's.
"What were the chances of that happening?"

The idea was to keep her out of the dance off, where the way things are going this year that could have included anyone.
The bad news was that despite their efforts she still ended up there. The good news was she ended up in there with Greg. So panic over, there's still two women left in the competition.
katmobile
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Doghouse Riley:
“The judges attempted to fix things by giving Claudia four undeserved 9s.
Whose idea that was is anyone's guess. I mean four nines including Craig's.
"What were the chances of that happening?"

The idea was to keep her out of the dance off, where the way things are going this year that could have included anyone.
The bad news was that despite their efforts she still ended up there. The good news was she ended up in there with Greg. So panic over, there's still two women left in the competition.”

I don't see why it's a big deal why there are still women in the competiton and I self indentify as a feminist some years the women are better than the men and some years it's the reverse. Some people entertain you and some don't - sometimes 'good' dancers are a bit dull and the 'bad' are entertaining. Like people said Jay was the last man standing for quite some considerable time last year and no one seemed to care despite women winning for the previous two years.
Dervlathedog
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Jennifer_F:
“Based on the dance off, I would have saved Greg. The jive was not a good dance for Claudia, she really didn't get the jive action at all, it was a fast and furious hot mess to me. However, whether thejudges made their decision, based on just the DO, who knows.”

Would the bouncy floor confuse a novice dancer doing a jive?
yellowlabbie
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by katmobile:
“You have got your way there is no reason to be a tit about it.”

And what about those who think Greg was robbed and are continually trashing Claudia's dancing? If they think Greg is better than Claudia then they are the tits.
Tweacle Tart II
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by katmobile:
“People always remember your mistakes don't they There was plenty of good stuff - the VW but yeah bring that up.”

Wow! Calm down.

He's a horribly boring dancer so yes, that is the only dance of his that I can actually recall. As for any of his others......no sorry, I got nothing.
notdebbiedingle
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Tweacle Tart II:
“Wow! Calm down.

He's a horribly boring dancer so yes, that is the only dance of his that I can actually recall. As for any of his others......no sorry, I got nothing.”

Personal taste I know, but I have to disagree with you on that one!!

In the routines that required 'a performance' eg the Robin Hood one, the Paso & Natalie's 'Rumba that wasn't a Rumba' I think he always delivered on that!! Fair enough his footwork was often a bit questionable & he was more than fortunate to escape the DO in Cha cha week but to say he was a boring dancer is a bit unfair imo!!
Jennifer_F
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Dervlathedog:
“Would the bouncy floor confuse a novice dancer doing a jive?”

I doubt it really, as it actually makes the dancing easier in my opinion. It probably felt different to what she is used to, but it would not affect her. The technique just was not there.
notdebbiedingle
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Littlegreen42:
“Such a shame this series has been ruined by the scoring. Judges obviously saving certain dancers (Ore and Joanne) mistakes mentioned yet award 10's while Greg puts everything into a dance and is only given an 8?

Claudia was awful both times, while Greg improved in the DO. Therefore he should have gone through.

But like Anita leaving before Katie last year, the Judges fix these things.”

Anita left last year because she made errors in a dance that was not what it was supposed to be!! I'll never understand why they chose to redo that 'salsa' rather than the Foxtrot which could have been ironed out into a great routine!! Katie was much better in the DO than she had been in the main show!! 5th was a wonderful result for Anita last year imo and all credit to Gleb & his stunning theatrical choreography that covered up her shortcomings!!

As for Ore & Greg on Saturday night, I'm a big fan of both but I'm sorry, Ore's routine & performance were a different class to Greg's & in my opinion apart from the outrageous overmarking of Claudia's first dance which left me speechless I think the rest were marked quite accurately!!
MaggieMcGee
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by FusionFury:
“Ed Balls would go, if it based purely on dance skills. Nobody likes to say it but Craig, the guy is as stompy as hell !

But it is not about dance ability, it is based on popularity and "personality" what is written in the press.

Gregg wasn't controversial or an "out there" personality, so he goes home sadly.

Well done Gregg for sticking to your beliefs/principals. A nice decent man who has done amazing things for this country and gone on an amazing journey with Natalie Lowe. Sleep well, sweet prince ”

What you forget is the partnership. Katya and Ed are a joyful couple with great senses of humour. Katya has choreographed clever routines, which have earned her praise for not letting Ed off the hook in terms of the steps, even if his technique leaves a lot to be desired. What's more their relationship has encouraged Ed to flourish performance-wise.

On the other hand the partnership between Greg and Natalie has turned me off Natalie again and Greg was dull to watch for those who are not his fans. I find this surprising as he seems to be a 'soul of the party' guy but between him and Natalie this lacked expression on the floor, aside from his opening jive. He should have gone last week against Daisy and outstayed his welcome afaic.
Domestos
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by notdebbiedingle:
“Anita left last year because she made errors in a dance that was not what it was supposed to be!! I'll never understand why they chose to redo that 'salsa' rather than the Foxtrot which could have been ironed out into a great routine!! Katie was much better in the DO than she had been in the main show!! 5th was a wonderful result for Anita last year imo and all credit to Gleb & his stunning theatrical choreography that covered up her shortcomings!!

As for Ore & Greg on Saturday night, I'm a big fan of both but I'm sorry, Ore's routine & performance were a different class to Greg's & in my opinion apart from the outrageous overmarking of Claudia's first dance which left me speechless I think the rest were marked quite accurately!!”

This ^^ I loved Ore's routine and he can outdance Greg, as nice as Greg is. Again, yes he and Louise had to be overmarked to put them in the right leader board position.
JohnStannard
21-11-2016
I don't think he was better than Claudia so not robbed in the Dance off in that way but should've gone further than Ed so in that way he was robbed
Tweacle Tart II
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by notdebbiedingle:
“Personal taste I know, but I have to disagree with you on that one!!

In the routines that required 'a performance' eg the Robin Hood one, the Paso & Natalie's 'Rumba that wasn't a Rumba' I think he always delivered on that!! Fair enough his footwork was often a bit questionable & he was more than fortunate to escape the DO in Cha cha week but to say he was a boring dancer is a bit unfair imo!!”

Fair enough. It would be boring if we all like the same people.

I want someone who makes me 'feel' something and he just did nothing for me. Same as Louise - yeah, I'm sure she's technically very good but Christ, she's so dull much like she is in real life.
LaughingSock
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“And what about those who think Greg was robbed and are continually trashing Claudia's dancing? If they think Greg is better than Claudia then they are the tits.”

Be fair. Claudia's jive was a mess. I've liked her dancing so far, but let's not get crazy and pretend that ALL her dances are wonderful. That jive wasn't, and while Greg's QS wasn't perfect, it was better than that jive. Probably not better than Claudia's dance last week, but DEFINITELY better than the dance she did on the week.

But somehow that suddenly doesn't matter in the DO when it's inconvenient.
Ms Babs
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Christopher D:
“Thankfully she was saved as their would have been only one woman left, The judges made the right choice.”

Surely it should be the the better dancer who,is saved ?
yellowlabbie
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by LaughingSock:
“Be fair. Claudia's jive was a mess. I've liked her dancing so far, but let's not get crazy and pretend that ALL her dances are wonderful. That jive wasn't, and while Greg's QS wasn't perfect, it was better than that jive. Probably not better than Claudia's dance last week, but DEFINITELY better than the dance she did on the week.

But somehow that suddenly doesn't matter in the DO when it's inconvenient.”

I agree it wasn't Claudia's best dance but it was far more difficult than Gregs. Greg did an ok dance well, Claudia did a difficult dance with a few little errors. It would have been a travesty is the judges had saved Greg over her.
yellowlabbie
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Ms Babs:
“
Surely it should be the the better dancer who,is saved ?”

Well the better dancer was saved.
LaughingSock
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“I agree it wasn't Claudia's best dance but it was far more difficult than Gregs. Greg did an ok dance well, Claudia did a difficult dance with a few little errors. It would have been a travesty is the judges had saved Greg over her.”

Why? Greg danced better. Maybe AJ should have thought about the difficulty of the dance and tailored it better to Claudia's abilities. Why should Greg be punished for it?
yellowlabbie
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by LaughingSock:
“Why? Greg danced better. Maybe AJ should have thought about the difficulty of the dance and tailored it better to Claudia's abilities. Why should Greg be punished for it?”

He wasn't punished, he was voted out by the judges and, anyway, why should Claudia be 'punished' because of AJ.

I'm sure Greg doesn't begrudge Claudia staying over him.
LaughingSock
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“He wasn't punished, he was voted out by the judges and, anyway, why should Claudia be 'punished' because of AJ.

I'm sure Greg doesn't begrudge Claudia staying over him.”

AJ is her partner. Celebs have fallen because of their pro's bungling before.

Of course Greg doesn't begrudge her. That's a ridiculous thing to add.
dippydancing
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by Christopher D:
“Thankfully she was saved as their would have been only one woman left, The judges made the right choice.”

I'm female- but I don't buy this as a reason for putting someone through: tokenism sucks. I'm with the many on here who say that Claudia's definitely better overall (her ballroom is looking really beautiful now) but in this DO, Greg kicked ass.

It's just so mealy-mouthed of the show to keep repeating that "the DO matters", and to dangle the carrot of allowing the lower marked dancer their dramatic chance to turn the tables, when clearly the judges just use it to put through "the better dancer"
I was totally expecting Len to go against the other 3 last night and say that Greg got his vote.
yellowlabbie
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by LaughingSock:
“AJ is her partner. Celebs have fallen because of their pro's bungling before.

Of course Greg doesn't begrudge her. That's a ridiculous thing to add.”

Maybe they have but that doesn't make it right.

It's just a pity most of his fans don't begrudge her or Ed. Poor Ed, he's not even in the bottom 2 and he's getting in the neck. It's not as if they are going to win anyway.
LaughingSock
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“Maybe they have but that doesn't make it right.

It's just a pity most of his fans don't begrudge her or Ed. Poor Ed, he's not even in the bottom 2 and he's getting in the neck. It's not as if they are going to win anyway.”

Perhaps he's getting it in the neck because he's not in the bottom two.

Still, I somehow think he'll survive this ~horrible abuse~.
yellowlabbie
21-11-2016
Originally Posted by LaughingSock:
“Perhaps he's getting it in the neck because he's not in the bottom two.

Still, I somehow think he'll survive this ~horrible abuse~.”

So that makes it OK? Maybe some of Greg's fans should follow his example and be gracious in defeat.
<<
<
4 of 5
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map