...to volunteer Scarlett for this royalty challenge?

"Scarlett, you'll be up for that won't you?"

He didn't give anyone else an opportunity to say they'd like to do it first.

i think she had discussed it before with him
because she said in the telegraph that she wants to take on every opportunity she gets

No right, that should of been a group choice.

Surely they should have discussed it as a group though, not just decided between them. It seems very unfair.

But they're not helpless babies!!. All they had to do is speak up if they wanted to do it.

And boy isn't she grabbing them

course they could, Larry even had to twist Lisa's arm in to it, the only other one to show a vague interest

Well, they both lost anyway *shrugs*

He's very forceful

Totally agree, said so on another thread. They should all have had equal opportunity, as it was a chance to win immunity. He shouldn't have just picked Scarlett, regardless of whether she'd already said she'd like to do it. Maybe the others didn't like to make a fuss?

The group had discussed it previously and Scarlett had said she wanted to do some trials.

I am sure if they were desperate to do it they could have opened their gobs and said so.

I'm convinced people on these threads think things are only discussed in the parts we see. They're together 24 hours a day - I'm pretty sure they've discussed who'll be up for anything and who'll speak up if they feel like doing it.