In 2011 at this point: Misha, Amelia, Marcus, Little Mix and Janet

2 of 2

big bang theory

29-11-2016

Originally Posted by GibsonSG:
“Righty ho, I get it now. I still come back to my point about not needing to dance. Did Leona, did Rebecca Ferguson? - both have good careers après X Factor.”

I can handle stripped back but Rebecca Ferguson took it way too far in her series imo.

manderley

29-11-2016

Originally Posted by big bang theory:
“I can handle stripped back but Rebecca Ferguson took it way too far in her series imo.”

Rebecca is able to laugh at herself and made this self deprecating video with a little help from a couple of the One Direction guys.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_NXRo8TThg

GibsonSG

29-11-2016

Originally Posted by big bang theory:
“I can handle stripped back but Rebecca Ferguson took it way too far in her series imo.”

She was my favourite that year, and ........ there is no need to dance if you have an interesting vocal. Did Leonard Cohen dance? - nope! Sold millions of records though. Does Bob Dylan dance? - Once more no, one of the biggest selling artists alive. I could go on but would it be worth my time.

Robert_Whippy

29-11-2016

Originally Posted by GibsonSG:
“Why does a singer have to dance? Can't they just sing? The only name listed above who I would agree with is little mix. The others were over hyped by the producers.”

I agree

Yes we need variety. But a singer doesnt have to dance. it seems an obssession now.

Simon moaning at Louis (for saying Emily should be dancing) saying SHES NOT A DANCER is all well and good but its a shame he didnt say the same with Lauren Platt

gavin shipman

29-11-2016

The best finals 5 was in 2008. That was the best ever series in my opinion too. 2014, 2011 and 2009 were great ones.

big bang theory

29-11-2016

Originally Posted by GibsonSG:
“She was my favourite that year, and ........ there is no need to dance if you have an interesting vocal. Did Leonard Cohen dance? - nope! Sold millions of records though. Does Bob Dylan dance? - Once more no, one of the biggest selling artists alive. I could go on but would it be worth my time.”

I can't comment on Leonard Cohen as much as I've only ever heard one song off him, but with Bob Dylan his songs weren't stripped back to oblivion I don't think.

E05297535

29-11-2016

Originally Posted by SULLA:
“Misha or Bisha B as she liked to call herself for no apparent reason, was dragged to the last 5 by the 'Judges'

They were at this stage. They were slow burners”

When did/does Misha ever call herself Bisha?? And because of Tulisa's verbal bile at her in public view, the GBP turned against her for no reason. ...Thank God Gary and Kelly saw talent in general. ..hence the deserving appreciation from them! !!!

Arthur_B

30-11-2016

Originally Posted by E05297535:
“When did/does Misha ever call herself Bisha?? And because of Tulisa's verbal bile at her in public view, the GBP turned against her for no reason. ...Thank God Gary and Kelly saw talent in general. ..hence the deserving appreciation from them! !!!”

Tulisa shouldn't have brought it all up in public, but if what Misha was being accused of was true (bullying), then you can hardly say she was turned on for no reason.

big bang theory

30-11-2016

Originally Posted by Arthur_B:
“Tulisa shouldn't have brought it all up in public, but if what Misha was being accused of was true (bullying), then you can hardly say she was turned on for no reason.”

It's highly unlikely that Misha B bullied 4 grown women, if any bullying was going on it would more than likely have been the other way around (I'm not saying that there was by the way) but I just find what Tulisa and Louis did was quite foul as they knew that the public thought that Misha had an ego anyway so they knew that the majority of the public would believe them even though it doesn't make much sense, and there also being no evidence to suggest that there was bullying going on in that dynamic, it just sounds like 5 egos went off and only Misha B was punished for it.

2 of 2