I couldn't listen to his second song yesterday, it was so painful I muted him. Matt is dreadful.
Matt's performance of Hurt was better than anything Saara has done
2 of 3
Originally Posted by zelda fan:
“No way, Saara regularly delivers way better performances.”
“No way, Saara regularly delivers way better performances.”
No she doesn't.
Originally Posted by xmel05:
“I can't believe he's in the bottom 2, that was a fantastic performance and one of the best of the whole series.”
“I can't believe he's in the bottom 2, that was a fantastic performance and one of the best of the whole series.”
Emily beat him hands down.
Oh dear - I have always liked Matt but he has been badly out of tune for a couple of weeks now and tonight was no exception.
I think there is a very good version of Hurt somewhere within that performance, but it needs to be done in the recording studio to smarten it up - a lot.
Another fan of Jamie Afro here.
I think there is a very good version of Hurt somewhere within that performance, but it needs to be done in the recording studio to smarten it up - a lot.
Another fan of Jamie Afro here.
Originally Posted by lady*tara:
“She was flat mat was much better imo”
“She was flat mat was much better imo”
That's the thing with these shows, everyone has a different perspective. I actually preferred Emily's performance, and technically she did hit more notes than Matt.
Matt was better than Emily.
I've heard SO many good versions of wings before.. that was just average with her weak voice.
I've heard SO many good versions of wings before.. that was just average with her weak voice.
Originally Posted by R598:
“Matt was better than Emily. I've heard SO many good versions of wings before.. that was just average with her weak voice.”
“Matt was better than Emily. I've heard SO many good versions of wings before.. that was just average with her weak voice.”
It wasn't even close. She destroyed him.
Originally Posted by xmel05:
“I can't believe he's in the bottom 2, that was a fantastic performance and one of the best of the whole series. How can people think Saara is better?”
“I can't believe he's in the bottom 2, that was a fantastic performance and one of the best of the whole series. How can people think Saara is better?”
He is awful I really can't stand him, his best performance was I'm your man and tgat was dire
Sara has killed him every week
He was in the bottom two because his performances weren't as good as the others. He looked very nervous last night, and he wasn't performing the way he can. That said Matt can still win anything can happen on this show.
Originally Posted by actually:
“He is awful I really can't stand him, his best performance was I'm your man and tgat was dire
Sara has killed him every week”
“He is awful I really can't stand him, his best performance was I'm your man and tgat was dire
Sara has killed him every week”
She is killing me every week this woman is so overated
Originally Posted by zelda fan:
“No way, Saara regularly delivers way better performances.”
“No way, Saara regularly delivers way better performances.”
Agree, and with far more superior vocals too.
Originally Posted by rsefitpro07:
“He was in the bottom two because his performances weren't as good as the others. He looked very nervous last night, and he wasn't performing the way he can. That said Matt can still win anything can happen on this show.”
“He was in the bottom two because his performances weren't as good as the others. He looked very nervous last night, and he wasn't performing the way he can. That said Matt can still win anything can happen on this show.”
Matt being in the bottom 2 can only help him next week honestly, with all his supporters voting for him like crazy to keep him at the top, just like what happened with 5AM, regaining voters after they realized they were in danger. However, Matt really should step it up if he wants to win in a deserving way.
Originally Posted by Since Yesterday:
“It wasn't even close. She destroyed him.”
“It wasn't even close. She destroyed him.”
I don't agree. Matt was not good, and yes Emily was more in tune than him, but he made a better connection with the song, and put in a better performance due to energy, dynamic contrast and emotion.
Emily has such a weak voice that she is only able to sing softly, and more softly still. This is very limiting. Song choices have to be so careful for this girl to play to her strengths. She has been criticised all series for not going up tempo, but I have never cared about this. I would have liked her to put in a performance with some kind of climax - but she is not capable of this.
Originally Posted by lady*tara:
“She is killing me every week this woman is so overated”
“She is killing me every week this woman is so overated”
Being completely honest, the whole top 3 is way too overrated. At least Saara keeps it fun and changes it around each week.
Originally Posted by Menk:
“Oh dear - I have always liked Matt but he has been badly out of tune for a couple of weeks now and tonight was no exception.
”
“Oh dear - I have always liked Matt but he has been badly out of tune for a couple of weeks now and tonight was no exception.
”
I don't get the dislike for Matt on here. I think he has been consistently good but it seems to me that recently he has been set up by being given the wrong songs. He is no longer being promoted as the next big thing.
Originally Posted by rsefitpro07:
“He was in the bottom two because his performances weren't as good as the others. He looked very nervous last night, and he wasn't performing the way he can. That said Matt can still win anything can happen on this show.”
“He was in the bottom two because his performances weren't as good as the others. He looked very nervous last night, and he wasn't performing the way he can. That said Matt can still win anything can happen on this show.”
BIB, I'm not Matt's biggest fan by any means, but the public do not put acts into the bottom two based off performances on the night, hence why Emily, Matt, and 5AM pulled through Disco week despite singing out of tune/miming parts.
That's just one example that I can think of just from this series.
Originally Posted by Menk:
“Matt was not good, and yes Emily was more in tune than him
but he made a better connection with the song, and put in a better performance due to energy, dynamic contrast and emotion.”
“Matt was not good, and yes Emily was more in tune than him
but he made a better connection with the song, and put in a better performance due to energy, dynamic contrast and emotion.”
Ergo, she beat him.
They were signing songs, not painting seascapes.
Originally Posted by big bang theory:
“BIB, I'm not Matt's biggest fan by any means, but the public do not put acts into the bottom two based off performances on the night, hence why Emily, Matt, and 5AM pulled through Disco week despite singing out of tune/miming parts.
That's just one example that I can think of just from this series.”
“BIB, I'm not Matt's biggest fan by any means, but the public do not put acts into the bottom two based off performances on the night, hence why Emily, Matt, and 5AM pulled through Disco week despite singing out of tune/miming parts.
That's just one example that I can think of just from this series.”
I think it's a combination of fan base + performance + order what decides who lands in the bottom two.
Also, by Disco week there still was Sam, Ryan and even Honey G who performed even worse than them, keeping them off the bottom two, also, Sam's and Ryan's fanbase was a lot smaller than the rest.
By now I get the feeling that most of them have the same fan base level, so that gives a lot more weight voting wise on how they perform.
2 of 3
