Originally Posted by dizzie:
“Drake - the biggest selling artist in the world - only 'just about cool' for you?!!! At least you admit this is purely about your personal sensibilities, but I promise you there is a vast range of music that people are into, and you're right at the far end of just one spectrum! After all, we're talking about the XF - the show who thinks it's totally OK to do My Heart Will Go On for the millionth time, or where Disco, Motown and Louis Walsh's cheesy picks are the height of entertainment. This is Saturday night TV we're talking about, not an R&B/Urban music gig! Adam Lambert will do very well, in this setting, and any 'cheese' in the performance will likely be exactly what the audience wants!”
Quite a lot of pathology there ^
There's a difference between someone being cool and popular. Katy Perry is popular but she isn't cool (for instance). Edgy, isn't really a thing in underground audiences but in popular music I think audiences have become a lot more comfortable with underground influences (look at the rise of Diplo for instance). Converesly Adam's music falls into the Kelly Clarkson/Pink/Mother's Day gift category (not that there's anything wrong with those artists or music types).
If you took the time to read my post before wearing out the exclamation point on your keyboard, you might have noted that I said it likely doesn't matter. I recognise I'm coming from a mid-twenties, postgrad sort of peer group so my music taste will be partially connected to that. I also said that he's talented and seems nice. No offense to him intended, he's just cheesey but, like you said, for a lot of the audience that will be just fine.