Originally Posted by Blondie X:
“Its all a bit odd. Matt was ridiculously over hyped for the first few weeks, had a bit more of a mixed reaction for a week or two and now Cowell is acting like he's been ripping the heads off of kittens.
Something has happened for Cowell to do such an about turn on his chose one so quickly”
I honestly think it was just how the competition went. There isn't a "behind the scenes" reason or anything like that.
Matt eas really hyped for the first weeks because he was one of the best at that time. He came strong from the whole Audition/6 Chair Challenge/Judge's Houses and performed very well, having stronger performances than most of the top 12/11/10 during the first couple weeks.
However, at that point a lot of other acts started to step it up.
Saara started to step it up since "It's Oh So Quiet", Emily had her moment a week after with "Creep", 5 After Midnight was also getting "better" and doing very entertaining performances. The whole Honey G "hype" kept going,
While at this was happening, and everyone was stepping up their game, Matt stayed at the same level, still being "good", but not really showing an improvement since he was already "good" since week 1.
I think that's why he started to be more harsh on him, because there wasn't any improvement with him.