Nope - I lost all respect for him when he humiliated Will Young. He should not speak to anyone like that at any time, let alone in front of millions of viewers. 
After that he was inclined to over compensate by being too nicey-nicey, which makes him look like he is not being genuine.
I wouldn't mind seeing 'guest' judges on the panel.

After that he was inclined to over compensate by being too nicey-nicey, which makes him look like he is not being genuine.
I wouldn't mind seeing 'guest' judges on the panel.




so that's a no, no, BBC.