Originally Posted by MrQuike:
“As far as I can tell, unless god makes an exception, it's fires of hell and no mistake. Islam makes a lot of not committing suicide.”
“As far as I can tell, unless god makes an exception, it's fires of hell and no mistake. Islam makes a lot of not committing suicide.”
That is too wide a statement to be useful. It is like saying Christianity frowns on murder. Whilst it is true, there are so many exceptions which vary in so many different sects that it is clearly not an absolute. The attitude to murder of a Quaker is clearly very different to that in Catholicism, or Jim Jones and yet they are all Christian.
Clearly the attitude to suicide killings, and sacrifice differs between the ISIS, Islamists, mainstream sunni and sufi. But they are all still clearly Muslim despite the denials of some.
So when someone says that's not Islamic it comes across as dishonest to many - since there are people clearly doing it in the name of Islam. It's more honest to say the Islam I believe in, or I grew up with etc doesn't believe that that is right than Muslims as a whole don't believe in X or Y.




, in a wrecked room/building)