Originally Posted by stenoboy:
“Neither Marx nor Weber, but rather the social group to which Max would belong - probably upper working class, for want of a better description. Anecdotally speaking, people from that group, in my experience, tend to look on America as the promised land.
Perhaps I expressed myself inelegantly, but this was NOT a snobbish opinion of his class, being from that same social group myself and hence my anecdotal knowledge of it.”
Now i can respect a little more the judgements you appear to be making and the reasons why. Nonetheless, I disagree with your assessment and think that, in general, notions, ideas, identification, self-identification, etc of class is far more complex and increasingly more fluid. Elderflower's simple conclusion makes far more sense within the context and circumstance.
You have, to a degree, some validity on the socio-political-idealogical aspirational views of certain classificational groupings...your anecdotal could prove 'typical' for many within the grouping you cite, the evidence does exist...however, i doubt it applies (exclusively) on this occassion.