with any luck i will be able to see Boom Town tonight. (broke my leg on Saturday night and was in hospital until 8pm sunday so missed both showings) need to see it befor Bad wolf comes on tomorrow 
Results:What did you think to the show?
Very Poor
16 (2.87%)
Poor
28 (5.02%)
Fair
71 (12.72%)
Good
152 (27.24%)
Very good
166 (29.75%)
Fantastic!
125 (22.40%)
Voters: 558. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Doctor Who 4th of June
33 of 33
Originally Posted by Yoonix:
“Don't think people are knocking RTD for his efforts at getting DW back on our screens, or the surrounding hype - what can we say? Tremendous job. Outstanding, even. But his writing... mmm... it really hasn't been the best, has it? In all fairness? Without wanting to start a fight here? Be honest, fellas...
To me, R's episodes have appeared poorly conceived self-indulgent twaddle with plot-holes you can drive a truck through. The series has been genuinely high quality overall, so it's a shame these episodes have kinda let the side down for many viewers. Perhaps he's a terrific writer, but just not when it comes to sci-fi?”
“Don't think people are knocking RTD for his efforts at getting DW back on our screens, or the surrounding hype - what can we say? Tremendous job. Outstanding, even. But his writing... mmm... it really hasn't been the best, has it? In all fairness? Without wanting to start a fight here? Be honest, fellas...
To me, R's episodes have appeared poorly conceived self-indulgent twaddle with plot-holes you can drive a truck through. The series has been genuinely high quality overall, so it's a shame these episodes have kinda let the side down for many viewers. Perhaps he's a terrific writer, but just not when it comes to sci-fi?”
Hey! be fair now!. I have really enjoyed this series and the only thing that was off putting was the Slitheens rubber suits
lol
Originally Posted by Yoonix:
“Don't think people are knocking RTD for his efforts at getting DW back on our screens, or the surrounding hype - what can we say? Tremendous job. Outstanding, even. But his writing... mmm... it really hasn't been the best, has it? In all fairness? Without wanting to start a fight here? Be honest, fellas...
To me, R's episodes have appeared poorly conceived self-indulgent twaddle with plot-holes you can drive a truck through. The series has been genuinely high quality overall, so it's a shame these episodes have kinda let the side down for many viewers. Perhaps he's a terrific writer, but just not when it comes to sci-fi?”
“Don't think people are knocking RTD for his efforts at getting DW back on our screens, or the surrounding hype - what can we say? Tremendous job. Outstanding, even. But his writing... mmm... it really hasn't been the best, has it? In all fairness? Without wanting to start a fight here? Be honest, fellas...
To me, R's episodes have appeared poorly conceived self-indulgent twaddle with plot-holes you can drive a truck through. The series has been genuinely high quality overall, so it's a shame these episodes have kinda let the side down for many viewers. Perhaps he's a terrific writer, but just not when it comes to sci-fi?”
rtd's strengths are in writing about human emotion which is tricky when you have a cast list of non-human characters.. i think the way he characterized rose has been fantastic, and her scenes have been some of the strongest in the series, but i think there has been a struggle to transfer that emotion to the non human characters..
personally i have been pleasantly surprised by rtd, only because i expected him to bring his own agenda to the series at the expense of it's illustrious history and this has in the most part not happened.. personally i think his strongest writing has been in series like bob and rose which i loved, although i look forward immensely to his continuing input into the series.. once the "new" dw has found its stride into the second series, i think we will see exactly what rtd can do with the show
Just in case people with Sky+ haven't seen this thread about tomorrow's episode:
http://forum.digitalspy.co.uk/board/...d.php?t=230677
Don't worry, no spoilers.
http://forum.digitalspy.co.uk/board/...d.php?t=230677
Don't worry, no spoilers.
I certainly have no complaints about his writing. I think, sometimes people try to pick at things uneccesarily and if that keeps you amused then fair enough. I just want to be entertained. And the current series does just that. I'll leave the fan-fights and nit picking to those who feel they need to.
*admin edit*
*admin edit*
Originally Posted by xxsammiexx2003:
“with any luck i will be able to see Boom Town tonight. (broke my leg on Saturday night and was in hospital until 8pm sunday so missed both showings) need to see it befor Bad wolf comes on tomorrow”
“with any luck i will be able to see Boom Town tonight. (broke my leg on Saturday night and was in hospital until 8pm sunday so missed both showings) need to see it befor Bad wolf comes on tomorrow
”
Happy birthday to you, happy birthday to you, happy birthday xxsammiexx, happy birthday to you!
(did everyone join in?)
I know it's late, and bad luck with the leg!
Originally Posted by xxsammiexx2003:
“hey all wish me happy birthday!.”
“hey all wish me happy birthday!.
”
just got back from a long trip in the time/space continuum, so happy birthday!
33 of 33
