Sorry about the new thread but I want something different.

Completely undecided between these two please tell me your fors and againsts these two nominees.

"cos hes fit or cos he's hunky" are not enough. Come on FM fight your corners

I don't want to be doing this......although I prefer Roberto over Derek, I do realise Derek is more entertainment value. But I will be hoping Roberto stays because;

1. I don't think Derek wants to be there anymore
2. I can't see Derek being as entertaining as he has, once his one ally, and one person near his age has gone.
3. I don't want to be in a position where if No2 is true, then Derek walks straight after. Then we'd lose both of them, and this show DOES need an adult, however, boring they are!

OH OH JO JO I DON'T KNOW KNOW

Both deserve to stay and both deserve to go go go.

Roberto - only creates tension when the subject is food - otherwise boring.
Roberto is I think a genuinely nice person.

Derek - will create tension about anything and everything.
Derek I think is a genuinely nasty person.

In the real world, I like nice people but hate nasty people. But this is not the real world and it should be judged merely on entertainment value. I think nastiness and tension can be entertaining if not overdone.
So I have to go with keeping Derek in. Roberto is too nice normally (out of food arguements) and does not have much entertainment value for me. Derek is a snidey b'stard and will be a bitch to anyone given the chance. Plus the fact for the second week in a row he has stressed his desire to leave. If he wants to leave then make him suffer and let him stay

I think Derek should stay. He is far more entertaining and his witty one-liners are must watch out for TV.

Roberto spends most of his time complaining about food, women find him attractive but that's about it.

Please GBP KEEP DEREK!!

Thanks

Interesting point. If anyone were to walk, I would say the most likely candidate would be Derek. If derek loses his ally then its quite possible he would want to leave.
can I change my previous post please?