• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Sarah Jane Smith to return to Doctor Who?
<<
<
2 of 4
>>
>
stuart62
25-07-2005
Originally Posted by jimboc:
“Oh please - have you seen Katy Manning recently? She would possibly pass as a Sea Devil...
”

Yes, her attempts to hold back time have not had the greatest of success really.
JohnFlawbod
26-07-2005
Originally Posted by jimboc:
“http://www.gallifreyone.com/news.php...AFylFlWIgTTCGk

According to the above, talks are underway with Elisabeth Sladen to make a come-back to Doctor Who.

I would LOVE to see a modern TV take on Sarah - past companion sharing notes with Rose, how travelling with him has affected her since, etc.

Any thoughts?”

If S J-S is now a hard-bitten tabloid newspaper editor a la Eve Pollard I will send a cheque doubling my licence fee direct to the DG by return of post...obviously without the cleavage, it being a family show and all...
ollyd1985
26-07-2005
Originally Posted by deaddog:
“great news, It would be good to see Rose deal with the fact she is only the latest of many. How many episodes is Sarah Jane in? My initial thoughts would be one or two.

I guess the plan of RTD to make the stories more "human" based is continuing in series 2.”

Although it may seem a long shot, I wouldn't be suprised if this new series (series 2 for the public, series 28 for the fans) had a couple of UNIT based stories, perhaps with a new Brigadier.

I am unable to comment on Sarah Jane Smith just yet. Maybe when I get round to buying copies of 'The Ark in Space' and 'Pyramids of Mars' on DVD.
jimboc
26-07-2005
Originally Posted by ollyd1985:
“I am unable to comment on Sarah Jane Smith just yet. Maybe when I get round to buying copies of 'The Ark in Space' and 'Pyramids of Mars' on DVD.”

She is very fondly remembered by many DW fans. I think mainly because she is such a fine actress and she stayed longer than most - 3 years.

She was also there when Jon Pertwee regenerated into Tom Baker, so will be able to offer Rose some (I'm sure) much needed advice.
chuffnobbler
26-07-2005
Very exciting news about Dame Sarah-Jane Smith making a return. Using her journalism would be the obvious way to do it. Interviewing Jackie and Mickey about their experiences? Meeting a Doctor who looks considerably younger than she does would be interesting viewing!

It's about time Elisabeth Sladen regained "proper" limelight, too, instead of ekeing out her days doing the convention circuit. A very underrated actress. I once read she was offered the role of the mother of the incest family in Brookside (the Simpsons?), but declined. She was always able to rescue the poorest of Doctor Who scenes, and SJ is a great character.

Love the new Doctor's costume, too.

chuff.x.
aussiewantsaps2
26-07-2005
I like the idea of Unit being more involved. We did see a bit of them in Series 1 but a new Brigadier type figure is needed. If it went well why not spin off Unit into its own show?
bigheather
26-07-2005
Originally Posted by stuart62:
“Yes, her attempts to hold back time have not had the greatest of success really.”

I like your wording ... very gentlemanly
stuart62
26-07-2005
Originally Posted by bigheather:
“I like your wording ... very gentlemanly ”

LOL. Yes, I was trying to be diplomatic!
Cookie Crumbler
26-07-2005
Originally Posted by chuffnobbler:
“Meeting a Doctor who looks considerably younger than she does would be interesting viewing!”

Not really, the scene would go something like this... (Bob Newhart, eat your heart out )

Doctor: "Sarah Jane! Lovely to see you again after so many years."

Sarah-Jane: "Sorry, do I know you?"

D: "It's me, The Doctor."

S-J: "Doctor? You've regenerated again?"

D: "Six times since I last saw you (Forget about The Five Doctors for a moment, Anoraks!)"

S-J: "Nice to see you again, your dress sense has... changed. Thats a very 1940s suit."

D: "Yeah, enough of that, listen, do you want a pound of sausages, genuine pork, sell 'em to you cheap, they fell off a lorry you see..."

OK, maybe not that last bit, but as we all know, she was there when JP changed to TB, so she wouldn't be surprised that he had changed.
JohnFlawbod
26-07-2005
Originally Posted by Cookie Crumbler:
“Not really, the scene would go something like this... (Bob Newhart, eat your heart out )

Doctor: "Sarah Jane! Lovely to see you again after so many years."

Sarah-Jane: "Sorry, do I know you?"

D: "It's me, The Doctor."

S-J: "Doctor? You've regenerated again?"

D: "Six times since I last saw you (Forget about The Five Doctors for a moment, Anoraks!)"

S-J: "Nice to see you again, your dress sense has... changed. Thats a very 1940s suit."

D: "Yeah, enough of that, listen, do you want a pound of sausages, genuine pork, sell 'em to you cheap, they fell off a lorry you see..."

OK, maybe not that last bit, but as we all know, she was there when JP changed to TB, so she wouldn't be surprised that he had changed.”

I'm not sure if this mounting sausage obsession won't get us all into a lot of trouble in the coming months
jimboc
27-07-2005
Originally Posted by JohnFlawbod:
“I'm not sure if this mounting sausage obsession won't get us all into a lot of trouble in the coming months ”

Story of my life....
Cookie Crumbler
27-07-2005
Originally Posted by JohnFlawbod:
“I'm not sure if this mounting sausage obsession won't get us all into a lot of trouble in the coming months ”

If a joke is good enough, its worth telling more than once to make sure everyone sees it

Well, someone said he looked like a spiv a la Private Walker from Dad's Army, and the only "deal" that I can think of is his trying to sell Jones (who, for those who have not seen Dad's Army, was a butcher) some sausages of dubious origin.

A Dad's Army anorak will no doubt post that he never tried to sell anyone sausages and its a figment of my imagination, and the whole conceit will get shot down in flames!
lonepiner
31-07-2005
Originally Posted by Cookie Crumbler:
“If a joke is good enough, its worth telling more than once to make sure everyone sees it

Well, someone said he looked like a spiv a la Private Walker from Dad's Army, and the only "deal" that I can think of is his trying to sell Jones (who, for those who have not seen Dad's Army, was a butcher) some sausages of dubious origin.

A Dad's Army anorak will no doubt post that he never tried to sell anyone sausages and its a figment of my imagination, and the whole conceit will get shot down in flames! ”

Don't panic! Walker would have sold ice to Innuits, given 'alf a chance. Sossies to Corporal Jones, I'm sure I remember that episode.

Good joke, btw ....
jimboc
31-07-2005
Originally Posted by lonepiner:
“Don't panic! Walker would have sold ice to Innuits, given 'alf a chance. Sossies to Corporal Jones, I'm sure I remember that episode.

Good joke, btw ....”

He just needs a pencilled-on moustache
Michael Boot
31-07-2005
Originally Posted by lonepiner:
“Problematical though McCoy's spell as the Doctor was - mainly due to the late John Nathan-Turner - he wasn't as bad as the robodog from hell, surely?

It will be cool to see the two best-ever Companions in harness together though ”

Have to possibly disagree- SJS was a fine character. However, I had a bit of a thing for Tegan, myself
lonepiner
31-07-2005
Originally Posted by Michael Boot:
“Have to possibly disagree- SJS was a fine character. However, I had a bit of a thing for Tegan, myself ”

That's what I'm saying, SJS was my favourite companion for all these years but Rose has come along with the differently-expressed but similarly superb results in terms of dramatic and emotional performance. So we actually agree, I hope?

You like Tegan, eh? I rather liked her fellow companion - no, not Adric - Nyssa ......
rua is god
01-08-2005
Peri was good, as long as she didnt talk, or do anything, ever. Wasn't a great actress, she looked good though.

I still think Rose is the best companion now, she does all the "doctor help me" stuff but doesnt complain about the danger every few minutes.
jimboc
01-08-2005
Originally Posted by Michael Boot:
“Have to possibly disagree- SJS was a fine character. However, I had a bit of a thing for Tegan, myself ”

Tegan was very good. V unlikely she'll return though, as Janet Fielding has said that hell must freeze over before she will return to the role...
Michael Boot
01-08-2005
Originally Posted by jimboc:
“Tegan was very good. V unlikely she'll return though, as Janet Fielding has said that hell must freeze over before she will return to the role... ”

What didn't she like about it?
romanwinecow
01-08-2005
On the subject of returns, I heard from a mate and also read another post on here from another reader saying that an old Doctor would be returning in series 2. Do you think Peter Davisons arrival on set late last week could be an indication of this?
lonepiner
01-08-2005
Originally Posted by romanwinecow:
“On the subject of returns, I heard from a mate and also read another post on here from another reader saying that an old Doctor would be returning in series 2. Do you think Peter Davisons arrival on set late last week could be an indication of this?”

PD in his old cricket whites and the eternal celery in his lapel? That would be, er .... interesting
romanwinecow
01-08-2005
Originally Posted by lonepiner:
“PD in his old cricket whites and the eternal celery in his lapel? That would be, er .... interesting ”

Pervert lol
jimboc
02-08-2005
Originally Posted by Michael Boot:
“What didn't she like about it? ”

She's been quite a full-on advocate of equal rights for women, etc since she left. Somehow she didn't think that screaming and running around corridors, while the guy got all the best scenes & lines, was a good role for a woman.

Things have moved on now, but you kind of see her point I suppose...
stuart62
02-08-2005
Originally Posted by jimboc:
“She's been quite a full-on advocate of equal rights for women, etc since she left. Somehow she didn't think that screaming and running around corridors, while the guy got all the best scenes & lines, was a good role for a woman.

Things have moved on now, but you kind of see her point I suppose... ”

Yes, her views are fair enough. Having said that, she's not slow to cash in on her involvement with the series through personal appearances, DVD commentaries etc.

For somebody who was so vocal about the role in the past, it seems a tad hypocritical to me.
jimboc
02-08-2005
Originally Posted by stuart62:
“Yes, her views are fair enough. Having said that, she's not slow to cash in on her involvement with the series through personal appearances, DVD commentaries etc.

For somebody who was so vocal about the role in the past, it seems a tad hypocritical to me.”

Good point - compare her attitude to Elisabeth Sladen who has continued to embrace her association with the programme and speak with fondness of her time as SJS. She has obviously benefitted from her attitude and the fans will always love her.

I loved Tegan too, but you're right, JF does seem a little ungrateful. After all she had some great stories - Kinda and Snakedance for example - when she had the opportunity to do more than the average companion actor.

It would be great to see Tegan now - and see the effect that her travels had on her long-term. To see her spar with the Doc now would be a treat.
<<
<
2 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map