Does anyone think that alex made the wrong choice in not taking kate to the rich side and only stirring things up for himself for the next nominations


Plus i hope jade gets nominated this week she will be out with more votes than lee

I agree that Alex should have taken Kate, plus I wanted Jade on the poor side.

alex shouldnt have taken kate
she wouldnt have chosen him under the same circumstances.

they havent spoken for weeks,why waste his choice--he was the winner.

If i was alex i wouldn't have taken Kate either,

I think that Alex was between a rock and a hard place (not that I have a lot of sympathy for the smug git) but don't forget it was Johnnys masterstroke of picking Sophie ahead of Tim that left Alex with his "Sophies Choice" dilemma,if Johnny had picked Adele clearly this would have been seen as spiteful by Johnny to deprive Simba of his lioness so he made Alex make the choice between his two adoring fans you could see how annoyed the petulant brat was in the bedroom afterwards he had won the task (fairly I might add) he got another week in heaven but he was still pissed that he couldn't have it all his own way like last week (classic mummys boy tantrums) . Also I think Kate would have been the last thing on his mind as he was pre-occupied with the Adele/Tim choice does anyone think that the permutations Adele,Tim Kate were ever running through his mind?. In the end it seems that Adele may have prompted him into the Jade choice (BBLB tickertape had some viewers stating that they overheard Adele saying "pick Jade") I've run the E4 on this a number of times and she may have said "pick Jade for me" can't be sure perhaps the techies in the backroom have a better idea (where's Gene Hackman when you need him)
Finally why did Alex take off his mike and only pick up to give his choices? perhaps it was a bit tight around the lump in his throat

[COLOR=limegreen]Hello, Pistachio here,[/COLOR]
I don't think Alex should have taken Kate either as they don't get on at all, what would be the point??
I really don't think he should have taken Jade though, maybe Tim?
I don't know, but Jade is really annoying me with her bitchy baby-talk, she is bitching about Sophie again!
Love
Pistachio

haven't we been through this?

Sorry been away since Friday night in Outer Mongolia trying to catch up tonight, bit difficult with so much happening

When Alex first made his choices I felt he was wrong not to choose Kate but now I'm not so sure. Do you think Kate would've appreciated Alex for picking her? No ... she'll think it was the right thing to do anyway and complain to Jonny and Sophie that Alex is a arse-licker for choosing her. And would we support Alex if he had pick Kate or will this forum be accusing him of being two-faced for leaving his mate Jade and choosing Kate simply to avoid being nominated for eviction.

All in all I think Alex's mistake was winning the musical chairs challenge. He should've let Tim win and therefore avoid all the flak and vitriol from the Jonny-Sophie-Kate camp (although i'm sure they'll be blaming him for something else).

By the way when did Sophie become best buddies with Jonny and Kate? She was the one who Alex risked everything for by picking to remain in the rich side for a second week (and whom she still picked for eviction despite all the sh*te Alex had to put up with from Jonny, PJ and Spencer for choosing her).

I seem to remember Alex telling Adele and Jade in the bedroom after the darts win and the blow up with Spencer and PJ "How could I tell them the real reason was that I didn't want those two smelly bastards over here" Bet you PJ now gets at least two showers a day and a toe jam inspection from our resident Howard Hughes

At last a person with some common sence and humanity.
Jade has bitched along with adele about everyone in the house apart from tim, she has been so over kate with cuddles and kisses then bitches horribly behind her back. Jade has also rubbed the poor house noses in it last week ,she needs to be in the poor house now , break her up from Adele

At last a person with some common sence and humanity.
Jade has bitched along with adele about everyone in the house apart from tim, she has been so over kate with cuddles and kisses then bitches horribly behind her back. Jade has also rubbed the poor house noses in it last week ,she needs to be in the poor house now , break her up from Adele

I believe that Alex made the right decision not choosing Kate. They don't get on so why take someone you dislike? In the diary room, Kate herself admitted she would not choose Alex!

At the end of the day it was his call and I'm sure whatever the choice he would have been critizised.

"You can't please all of the people all of the time." (contrary to what Johny thinks!)

Alex had a tough decision. I may have taken kate over as a tactical move to avoid nomination. He must know that she is a dead cert. I thought he over reacted a little afterwards - I appreciate it's not a nice thing to have to do, but still........
I think the only winner of the task was Adele - she gets to stay on the Rich side with her two chums, Alex and Jade.

Alex is such a drama queen though, the way he played with his microphone afterwards and made out he didn't know he had to choose again, what rubbish, him and Tim practically discussed this when they were left alone and the task clearly said as such, he just wants people to feel sorry for him and the decisions he has to make......get rid of him, least Spencer had a back bone....

Sorry to burst your anti-Sophie bubble, but she didn't nominate Alex, she nominated Jade and Spencer.

I think its not a case of being best buddies with Jonny and Kate, more that everyone else in the house dislikes her, so she doesn't have anyone else left to talk to.

ooops my mistake

Now that my Anti-Sophie bubble has indeed burst I feel just sorry for her. However for the sake of her sanity I still believe it's best for Sophie to leave the house as quickly as possible. During the past week she's looking more and more like an escaped mental patient hobbling along aimlessly in her dirty white dressing gown. I fear that one night the other HMs will go "Lord of the Flies" on her and pummel her to death with empty wine bottles and chipsticks.

Glad i wasn,t the only one who saw this

[quote]Originally posted by nickwightwick
[b]Does anyone think that alex made the wrong choice in not taking kate to the rich side and only stirring things up for himself for the next nominations

I understand the pj choice........would have been seen as a sadistic bastar*d if not and really alex is not sadistic bastar*d just a sad bastar*d.
Again undersatnd the adele choice.......oh alex your great, oh alex i fancy you, oh alex i am soooo clean
BUT jade?????? My head is still hurting over that one......i mean she called him a batty boy to his face????
It hurts to try and figure out alexs logic

the Jade choice I believe is purely because he dislikes Kate more than he likes Jade, if that makes any sense.

I just felt that johnny gave him certain decisions to make when picking the people he had with him and that picking jade over kate he made it very clear that he doesnt like kate and made the rest of the group see that i think very cunning of johnny and a definate for alex to be up for eviction again this week

I'm overjoyed he choose Jade because if he hadn't we wouldn't have had this great moment last night as the rich side went to bed:

Jade 'Can everyone be quiet, I need to get my beauty sleep'

Alex 'See you Friday then'

LOL!!