I've nothing against him at all and he's a good singer but I just find him really unexciting and bland.

Is it just me?

No - not just you.

I can't abide the man.

Hi, ZG! Sympatico, again!

Yo, Kim! Looks like it!

I find Andy so complacent and drooling with his own 'fabbyness'. Don't like him at all.

Thought he was the most boring out of them all last night...just seemed to be going on and on and on. How does he get great comments from the judges coz I don't see it.

I hate him, plus he gives me the creeps. Im not sure why but theres just something about him.

I like his voice. I usually like him but he bored me rigid last night.

I don't see that there is anything special about his story. What is the difference between him getting up every morning to go to work and any of the other contestants? Whatever the time of the morning and whatever the job is?

I agree he does seem to be getting a bit too complacent. I hope I'm wrong but I think he could turn out to be everything Sharon tried to accuse Steve of being last year, just a far better actor.

You're not the only one. I don't really like him and I think he is quite dull - found him incredibly boring last night and couldn't understand the judges going crazy over him (Maria and Brenda were better IMO and Journey South were more fun).

I agree that Andy definitely hasn't got what it takes to be a winner.

He is what he is........a long time tryer who has done a lot of gigs but doesn't go beyond being just another singer with a halfway decent voice.

I do think that he is becoming a bit wrapped up in his own perceived glory!

It will be a sad awakening for him when he eventually leaves as I don't think that the phone will be ringing off the hook for him once he goes back home to an ordinary life.

dull very smarmy

good singer he should stay as he is, a backing singer

Great voice, but lacked the showbiz X Factor last night...

Oh, good! I was almost nodding off (exaggeration) when he was singing and I don't know much about him but they do seem to be selling some kind of sob story with him. I think he may make it to the last show though. And he looks like a duck.

Brenda and Journey South were amazing last night. There was real star quality about their performance.

Maria leaves me cold. OK voice but otherwise totally horrible.

Brenda was fantastic. Hard song to sing too.

I agree with you totally.
I think it is quite apt that he used to collect rubbish,it has had an affect on his performances!

Bored me rigid last night and I cant understand the praise he is receiving either.

i dont like to say but i found brenda boring last night

Yeah. Maria isn't really the kind of singer I would follow or buy the albums etc, but she did give it some welly last night and you couldn't call her performance "dull" the way you could Andy's. I do prefer Brenda and Journey South.

No problem! I'm sure loads of other people did too. I'm sure she won't win but I would quite like her to.

i'm not kene on andy nevr have been.I dont doubt he has a good voice but, to me he dont have the x factor i much prefer chenai maria brenda journey south and shayne.i really didnt like his performance at all last night.

i dont like him much, i think hes very false.

I guess all you lot are under 20 years old, makes me sick when a good genuine guy comes along and all people can do is slag him off.

Grow up all of you.

Well I am definately in the over 20's and although i think Andy is a good singer, I found last nights performance very boring but I think its more to do with song choice than his actual persona, as I really enjoyed him doing Greatest Love of all.

Good grief. We're allowed to have our opinions. There's no need to be rude just because you have a different one.

I'm over 20, as you can see from my profile, and everyone here of whatever age is entitled to an opinion.