Goodness knows why Simon chose the talentless girls over 4thBase. I wasn't a huge fan of the boys but at least they had grit & determination. Also they had a certain charisma about them.
Who would you have preferred to see in Simon's top 4?

Conway Sisters

I can't really remember which one of the boring bands 4thBase was but I'd definitely put them in over Addictiv Ladies. I think out of a weak bunch of groups I might have put the Conway Sisters in, or maybe the other duo instead of them. The act that should never have been there was definitely the Addictiv Ladies as they had absolutely nothing!

The Brothers instead of addictiv ladies...
4thBa5e instead of Conways....
There would have been a cool battle of the boy bands!!!!

I haven't heard any of the earlier acts this year. But I would still say Simon should have kept 4thBase rather than having to suffer listening to the Conways.

Conways deserve their place - definitely!
Addictiv Laydees didn't - 4th base or Eskimo Blonde should have been in instead!

I agree, Conway's and Addictiv Ladies are complete garbage. I have no idea what Cowell was thinking of.

I prefer the conways to 4thBase.

4thBase

In fact anyone would have done instead.

conway sisters

Neither - I would have left the spot open for the tweenies - they are better than either of them.

yeah definately the brothers in, instead of addictive ladies, and eskimo blonde in, instead of the conway sisters!

The Brothers instead of Addictiv Ladies, The Conway Sisters over of 4thbase, and not Eskimo blonde, as they only had only one good singer.

i cannae mind who 4th base were again anyone want to enlighten me? i watched it all the way through but my minds went blank at who they were what did they look like?

They were the five guys who kept messing up - a bit wierd looking.

The conway sisters deserved to be in the top 4.
I didn't like 4th ba5e very much but if i had chosen anyone to put them in instead of it would've been the addicitve ladies

right i know who they were i thought they were meaning it was a girl group for some reason, yeah all looked very different but even though they ****ed up all the time they were quite good!

The Conway Sisters deserve to be there.

4thBa5e (if they could ever remember their words ), the Brothers or even Eskimo Blonde should have been in instead of Addictiv Ladies. I don't know what Simon was thinking when he put them through.

I didn't rate 4thBa5e at all. How many times did they mess up? They were no good.

The Brothers and Eskimo Blonde should have been in the final four.

Even though I really, really like The Conways, I do think these two acts would have been better choices. Simon may still have a few acts left if Addictiv Ladies and The Conways hadn't been put through.

Exactly, there was no way Simon could put through 4thbase - they were in the final 7 and he gave them plenty of chances but they were completely unable to perform under any sort of pressure - they didn't manage to sing one song properley

I quite liked the Brothers at one point - surely better than Additictiv Ladies! I think the Conway Sisters deserve to be there though.

4th base>conways>adictive ladies

4th Base had the advantage of being able to sing. The conways have the most interesting teeth. The addictive ladies...huh

The problem with the group category is that they don't seem to pick them on talent alone. They don't want two similar groups to go through, so although the Brothers and 4thBa5e were more talented than the Addictiv ladies, they would have picked them according to who was the best boy band ie Fortune, that way they end up with 4 different acts. It would be fairer if they just picked the best.

yeah if id been simon i would have put eskimo blonde in instead of the conways
the brothers instead of addictive ladies
and id have kept 4tune and journey south.

Should've been Journey South, The Brothers, 4Tune and The Conway Sisters (however much I dislike them)... he couldn't really have put three boybands through, might as well have a variation.