Straight man in the audience here!
She does nothing for me, I'm afraid. She reminds me of that old sketch (was it Spitting Image?) with two fashion models represented by pipe-cleaners with boobs and hair. She has no sex appeal whatever - even when she dresses sexy it doesn't work very well.

Don't get me wrong, she seems a nice enough kid on 24/7 etc, but that's it.

Corrections
1. A pretty good voice - eliminates Chico
2. Personality - eliminates Nicholas,Maria
3. Originality - eliminates Conways, Shayne,Brenda
4. Ooomph - eliminates Andy
5. Not taking yourselves too seriously (you are entertainers for Gods sake) - eliminates JS

Originality
eliminates ALL of them

Not many. Look at any site and you'll see that most of her support is coming from women (and let's face it she needs all she can get as that "The Way You Make Me Feel" outfit showed ). Men generally don't seem to think she's anything to write home about.

This is exactly almost word for word what my dad said.