Tonight he is signing Justin and there is no way he can pull that song off without looking like a pratt. Hopefully he will be in the bottom two with Maria and Shane can then go home.

Your opinion
I personally don't mind Shayne, but I think Justin Timberlake was a bad song choice for him
I would like the bottom 2 to be Andy and Conway Sisters
I can't decide who leaves, as I am not very big fans of either of these two acts

Maria & Shayne in the bottom two? Dream on!

If Shayne is rubbish then I must double-check my wheelie bin ASAP.

wait for it!


the clone rip off comment will be posted next

imo he is just ripping off JT - just trying to be a clone..


(so as not to dissapoint you SRUS )

well i knew it would'nt be long

to be fair even if he makes an awful performance tonight, i dont think he will go out...or even be in the bottom 2.

think about nicholas last week, his song was crap yet he managed to stay, not for his performance on the night, but because overall he was seen to have better prospects... i still voted for him because im a fan of him and i think previous performances were great.. and even tho he performed pretty poor last week i still didnt want him to go out, which i think shayne fans will feel too.

The reason people keep making the clone comment is because it's true! There is no way Shayne can perform that song the way he is without looking like a poor mans Justin.....

Wow another thread about Shayne. Well, i dont think he can pull it off either but he will get through next week , its all a fixed show. Its either Conway Sisters or Chico out this week, maybe Nicholas.

I dont like Shayne at all, i think he should go this week.

I'm hoping the judges will criticise Shayne this week for not bringing anything of his own to the performance. I believe it's only fair....

But how do you know he won't? Unless you watched ITV2 yesterday of course, lol.

He might completely change the track to suit him.....a far fetched idea I know.......but he might.........

Shayne sounded absolutely fab in his soundcheck and how anyone can say he is "rubbish" is beyond me. I also think he is much better looking than Justin Timberlake too!

I don't like Shayne, but a lot of peeps do and theres no way he's gonna be in the bottom 2 tonight, i wish!

I saw him rehearse it on the X-tra factor yesterday and he ws really good. Don't shot him down before he's even performed.

Yeah, i'm basing my opinion on what i saw on ITV2 last night. If he changes his performance so it's less Justin-like then i will take it back

I think people are just pointing out that actually, this performance IS just like Justin's own. If he wasn't doing the Justin moves, then it would have been ok and i don't think anyone would have bought it up.

If they are in the bottom two it isn't a certainty that Shayne would go. Louis would vote out Maria, Sharon would vote out Shayne, thus leaving Simon - don't forget that Sharon has all four of her acts still, and Simon loves Shayne.

Rival fans are getting worried. You can tell when the anti-threads start appearing everywhere. Interesting most of the anti-posts are coming from Journey South fans.

Is that true? Didn't notice that!

Yes its true. Journey South are my second favourites as well.

is that a justin clone comment

i was wating for a few more

He's not really a clone....more like a copy. He's not as good as Justin.
The whole idea of a forum is to give comment so if people think shayne is a Justin clone then they must have a reason for thinking that?

not a clone!!!!

but now a copy

He hasnt even sung a Timberlake song yet and he is already being compared.

whatever people say about shayne my choice is shayne to win the x factor and if he dont im sure hes got a record deal already, look at chenai shes doing gigs already they all will do good from it