your scores for 12th november show

2 of 3

~V~

13-11-2005

scores up to DreamingGirl (21 votes)
[list=1][*]colin and erin 136[*]zoe and ian 131[*]james and camilla 118[*]Darren and lillia 111[*]bill and karen 95[*]patsy and anton 71[*]will and hanna 66[*]dennis and izabella 28[/list]

Seymour

13-11-2005

8.Zoe and Ian
7.Colin and Erin
6. Will and Hanna
5. Darren and Lilia
4. Bill and Karen
3.Patsy an Anton
2.James and Camilla.
1. Dennis and Izabella

Aida

13-11-2005

8 Colin and Erin (sorry Ian and Zo - had to be honest)
7 Ian and Zoe
6 Darren and Lilia
5 Will and Hanna
4 James and Camilla
3 Anton and Pasty
2 Dennis and Izabella
1 Bill and Karen

catbabe

13-11-2005

8.Darren and Lilia
7.James and Camilla
6. Zoe and Ian
5.Colin and Erin
4. Bill and Karen
3.Patsy an Anton
2.Will and Hanna
1. Dennis and Izabella

Purplehaze

13-11-2005

Originally Posted by ~V~:
“to be honest, i don't think it matters, especially to you who hasn't played along

some people vote according to what they see, others are more biased. just like the judges but to a probably greater extent.

people are free to discuss the scores if they wish, but derision of what somebody thought was the best dance (as has been done here) is far more out of order than voting for a favourite dancer don't you think?

anyway, there are enough people voting honestly that it all straightens out, as you will see”

Here here well said. Its only a bit of fun

And my votes are as follows

8 Colin & Erin
7 Darren & Lilia
6 Bill & Karen
5 James & Camilla
4 Zoe & Ian
3 Anton & Patsy
2 Will & Hanna
1 Dennis & Isabella ( although it did make me laugh)

lady-muck

13-11-2005

Forgive my babble, but wanted to add my thoughts on the performances...

8: Colin & Erin
By a long way. Sorry Zoe fans, but I don't understand the fascination with the Zoe n' Ian show. I didn't like their samba at all. Colin and Erin were extraordinary to watch. Not perfect - lost sync with each other a couple of times - but from the heart and soul, and with natural grace, joy and everything a samba is supposed to be.

7: James & Camilla
Better than they were given credit for being. Yes James is too stiff, and he still had that "tango hand", but there was plenty of grace and heart in their waltz.

6: Darren & Lilia
A very close call between Darren and James. Darren was possibly technically better, but James and Camilla gave a more engaging performance.

5: Bill & Karen
Amazing performance, considering the sprain. That had to ***ing hurt. I'm starting to think that Bill's a dark horse to watch.

4: Zoe & Ian
Yeah yeah blah blah. Agree with marmyte.

3: Will & Hanna
Will is also too stiff and it seemed unnatural, but I don't think it was nearly as bad as the scores suggested.

2: Patsy & Anton
Sorry, I don't think she has any grace at all. The most overrated of the lot.

1: Dennis & Isabella
Dad dancing at a wedding. And not a dad who goes to ballroom classes.

lady-muck

13-11-2005

Originally Posted by atynesider:
“Isn't it about time you stopped this thread. It seemed to start off with people giving their honest assessments of the dancing, flavoured with a little bias towards their favourites. Now it is just lists of favourites. No one in their right mind could say that Bill and Karen were the best, or Anton and Patsy, or Will and Hanna.”

Well I like the thread (even if I broke the rules by babbling in my post!)

Part of the enjoyment of SCD is that we all have our own idea of how the couples did, and of where we agree/disagree with the judges.

Ibby73

13-11-2005

8.Darren and Lilia
7. Zoe and Ian
6.Bill and Karen
5.Will and Hanna
4.James and Camilla
3.Colin and Erin (Sooooo out of time)
2.Patsy an Anton (I wish Patsy would shut up and I get the feeling they don't get on)
1. Dennis and Izabella

Kez100

13-11-2005

8 C and E
7 Z nad I
6 J and C
5 B and K
4 D and L
3 W and H
2 P and A
1 D and I

Sorry, working away from home, can't cut and paste and in a hurry!

marmyte

13-11-2005

Originally Posted by bendymixer:
“haha your having a larf arent ya Patsy and Anton 8 !!!!!!!!! Faints”

as other people have said, we all have different opinions. patsy isn't my favourite by a long way, but i think she's entertaining, and i thought zoe was horrendous last night and couldn't believe how much the judges praised her. in all honesty i agree with what some people have said in that it was quite average last night and i think some of them peaked too soon in the competition. i came very close to putting darren and lilia top because i've been voting for them the whole time, but that wouldn't have been honest of me

and yes, actually, i am having a "larf" because it's just a bit of fun

Elisabeth92

13-11-2005

8. Darren and Lilia
7. Zoe and Ian
6. Colin and Erin
5. Patsy and Anton
4. James and Camilla
3. Dennis and Izabela
2. Will and Hanna
1. Bill and Karen

bliss_assassin

13-11-2005

8. Bill and Karen
7. Colin and Erin
6. James and Camilla
5. Darren and Lillia
4. Zoe and Ian
3. Dennis and Izabella
2. Patsy and Anton
1. Will and Hanna

PeachUK

13-11-2005

Originally Posted by atyneside:
“Isn't it about time you stopped this thread. It seemed to start off with people giving their honest assessments of the dancing, flavoured with a little bias towards their favourites. Now it is just lists of favourites. No one in their right mind could say that Bill and Karen were the best, or Anton and Patsy, or Will and Hanna.”

I do believe that Bill & Karen gave the most entertaining performance. I was excited by them - not because they were my favourites because they have excited me through their performance. They made me smile the most which means their DANCE made me smile the most which in my opinion makes them have the best dance of the night.

I thought Colin was excellent but didn't blend as well with Erin - he snaked a bit too much. I enjoyed Zoe & Ian and thought at the time "yes, she's doing really well". When I watched Bill & Karen my reaction was more like "Wow! They're doing that! And the end was amazing!" I beamed from start to finish and who do I want to rewind my video to watch.. you got it.. Bill & Karen.
We are after all voting for our favourite COUPLE not our favourite celebrity and I think that Bill & Karen are the most COUPLE-like of all of the competitors.

Well said.

~V~

13-11-2005

Originally Posted by lady-muck:
“Well I like the thread (even if I broke the rules by babbling in my post!)”

babble all you like. i don't think there are any rules apart from giving scores

plus it keeps me on my toes

~V~

13-11-2005

ok, here are the results so far after 30 votes
[list=1][*]colin and erin 196[*]zoe and ian 185[*]Darren and lillia 168[*]james and camilla 163[*]bill and karen 135[*]patsy and anton 96[*]will and hanna 95[*]dennis and izabella 42[/list]

beamingfrog

13-11-2005

1. Zoe & Ian
2. Colin & Erin
3. James & Camilla
4. Darren & Lilia
5. Will & Hanna
6. Bill & Karen
7. Patsy & Anton
8. Dennis & Izabella

T&W

13-11-2005

1. Colin & Erin
2. Bill & Karen
3. Zoe & Ian
4. Darren & Lilia
5. James & Camilla
6. Patsy & Anton
7. Will & Hanna
8. Dennis & Isabella

morpar

14-11-2005

Zoe & Ian - 8
Colin & Erin - 7
James & Camilla - 6
Darren & Lillia - 5
Bill & Karen - 4
Will & Hannah - 3
Patsy & Anton
Dennis & Izabella

Basically, Zoe & Ian were far better than everyone else. Colin over did the hip action - made Erin look ordinary. The obvious chemistry between James & Camilla helps them look so good. Darren surprises me every week. Bill did well considering that foot. Will wasn't as good as I had expected. Patsy and Anton - what the heck was that?

Finally, Dennis should have gone weeks ago.

lady-muck

14-11-2005

Originally Posted by morpar:
“Basically, Zoe & Ian were far better than everyone else. Colin over did the hip action - made Erin look ordinary. The obvious chemistry between James & Camilla helps them look so good. Darren surprises me every week. Bill did well considering that foot. Will wasn't as good as I had expected. Patsy and Anton - what the heck was that?

Finally, Dennis should have gone weeks ago.”

Don't agree with every word of that, but it beautifully summed up Saturday's show.

Can you do that every week please?

~V~

14-11-2005

lycheechill and T&W am i to take it you meant those in that order but just didn't score them?

PurpleAngel

14-11-2005

Colin and Erin
Zoe and Ian
James & Camilla
Darren & Lillia
Bill & Karen
Patsy & Anton
Will & Hanna
Dennis & Isabella

i do think the judges are more lienient towards Zoe and Ian as Colin and Erins performance was so much better but didnt score as well but like Erin said it wasnt a bit more riske

~V~

14-11-2005

Originally Posted by PurpleAngel:
“
i do think the judges are more lienient towards Zoe and Ian as Colin and Erins performance was so much better but didnt score as well but like Erin said it wasnt a bit more riske”

not sure, i didn't like colin and erin's performance one little bit

PurpleAngel

14-11-2005

Originally Posted by ~V~:
“not sure, i didn't like colin and erin's performance one little bit”

see i didnt like zoes i thought she looked quite clumsy doing the latin

~V~

14-11-2005

that's why this is kinda good. shows who the majority rated

so far, we've agreed with who went home every week

beamingfrog

14-11-2005

Originally Posted by ~V~:
“lycheechill and T&W am i to take it you meant those in that order but just didn't score them?”

yep sorry! did it late at night.

thanks for doing this ~V~ is a great idea!

2 of 3