Shayne VS Nicholas - Page 2 - Digital Spy Forums

Shayne VS Nicholas

2 of 2

thms

15-11-2005

Originally Posted by Poodledoodledoo:
“I think we are being fed Shayne on purpose. My theory is that he has already been selected as the winner so everything we read or see regarding the X Factor is biased towards Shayne. It is very odd that Nicholas has had less press coverage than Shayne, when i think he is just as appealing to young teenagers. I think it's all a ploy to brainwash us into voting for the guy. ”

great minds think alike

see my last post
it's in the shayne appreciation thread

anna123

15-11-2005

Originally Posted by thms:
“imo nicholas's support is growing rapidly despite
having two truly dreadful song choices in a row
and is holding his own against these seasoned pros
yup the boy has done good, a natural performer
all we want is a brilliant song for him to sing...
come on louis stop bumming up shayne”

if he does a good performance i'll vote for him as he seems like a really genuine guy but he needs to get a decent song and sing it well or he'll be out soon

NewWoman

15-11-2005

I agree. I dont really see anything special in Shayne tbh.

I reckon that, because we havent had a 'pop idol' type winner for a few years now, they want that type to win this time round and Shayne is the chosen one.

thms

15-11-2005

Originally Posted by anna123:
“if he does a good performance i'll vote for him as he seems like a really genuine guy but he needs to get a decent song and sing it well or he'll be out soon ”

those last two songs might put a dent in his chances
whatever the judges are up to, nicholas isn't phased
if he keeps being himself we will have 'decent' winner

NewWoman

15-11-2005

I'd like to hear Nic try 'Let me Love You' by Mario. Its an up to date song and suits his style.

*Jodz_2307*

15-11-2005

i thought Nicholas was good when i saw him in his first audition but i dont like him anymore, everytime he sings he sounds flat but i would like to hear him sing end of the road again because he was good at that, Louis is giving him the wrong songs

Xxclaire89xX

15-11-2005

Originally Posted by anna123:
“I think nicholas comes across like a nicer person, he just seems so genuine.
But Shayne has the better voice.
Every week i really want to vote for Nicholas as hes such a sweet guy and seems very humble but his performances always dissapoint me so i just cant bring myself to pick up the phone and actually vote for him.
He should have gone the week he was in the bottom 2 imo.”

Yeah I know what you mean, although I do vote for him. I just know he can do so much better if he had a fantastic song. The fact that he was so good when he sung Let's Get It On proves this. I didn't vote for him when he did I Want You Back because he was just truly awful and I had a feeling he would be in the Bottom Two anyway. I didn't like I Believe I Can Fly very much either, but voted for him FOUR times regardless...

I voted for him on Saturday mainly for piece of mind, as I couldn't of bared it if he went after Chenai left just the week before.

PrincessJilly

15-11-2005

i feel exactly the same claire, im still voting for him despite his weaker performances, coz we've seen previously that he is capable of more

anna123

15-11-2005

Do you think itws just down to nerves?
Maybe he'll be more confident this week as he was saved by the public on saturday.

PrincessJilly

15-11-2005

its deffo nerves....listen to his songs, u can even here in the space of a song how he picks up confidence. he starts of a bit shaky then improves....can hardly blame him tho. i have a good singing voice but i know that if faced with a live performance like that my voice would be shaky as **** with nerves...

2 of 2