Originally Posted by GlenP:
“Sure would. I used to get just as annoyed with CRH when he was doing his "Mr. Nasty" routine.
Fine, criticise the dancing, if you must but try to make it constructive & no personal.”
I agree entirely, I don't have any ill feeling against Arlene because she is a woman. I believe that proper criticism politely delivered, will be well regarded by by everyone (contestants viewers and fellow judges) and given the respect it deserves.
My dislike is for Arlene's attitude and lack of manners. There is no need to make personal attacks on the contestants and using words such as "disgusting" and disgraceful" etc give no direction at all to the contestants.
If she were to criticise by giving a decent description of what she thought was wrong and why I'm sure most people would feel differently toward her.
I know that some people on this forum excuse Arlene by saying you have to be hard in the pro dance world, I agree but manners are free and Arlene is not competing against them.
She now has a struggle to say anything at all on the show and she only has herself to blame for that as it is purely down to her unpleasant sarcasm.
CRH is not adverse to making unpleasant, unhelpful remarks either but at least he seems to have learned and tries now to be more constructive.