If Andy wins, I'll be very, very happy.
If Journey South wins, I'll be pleased for them.
If Shayne wins, I'll be angry and upset. I can't stand him.

Shayne.

Andy is Steve Brookstein - boring and there's no market for crooners.

And I don't get JS. They just seem like good pub singers, and are kind of cheesy (especially last week!).

Do I detect a note of running down the competition?
Last edited by Acashoonhay : 13-12-2005 at 23:46

I love that JS are way in front on this poll They seem quite popular on this forum and on the This Morning poll

I can't believe JS are winning the vote...they stink as much as old man's pants!

Then again Steve....erm...somthing won last year.

I wonder where he is now....back in the pubs I suppose!

Andy to win....or come second and have a bigger career than anyone al la G4.

Mmmm...Steve....erm......

It's probably just me who thinks this, but Journey South seem very quiet. They haven't stood out as much as the other contestants. For instance, I only found out their names last Saturday.

Karl is the weirdest one. It's as if he's not even part of the competition. He just comes on, does his thing, and goes. Their performances have barely registered.

I do like them though, a lot more than Shayne Grimshaw.

Are you trolling ?

You seem to have just joined and are making negative posts about acts that either have nothing to do with this poll, or just negative posts fullstop.

This is a poll thread.

That makes him sound like a ghost

Shayne!

Don't get the attraction with JS myself. They were terrible last Saturday.

Each to their own

I voted Shayne as I believe that he has the most potential. I would be quite happy for either of them to win

I'm glad Journey South are winning the poll (not that that means anything)!
I don't think they'll win though.
If they don't win, I'm hoping it will be Andy.
But I don't think he will either.
Which isn't good because I don't like Shayne much and I think he'll be the winner.

Life would be dull if everybody liked the same things!

they'll all have careers outta this.. cos they actually HAVE got talent, andy for his amazing crooning ability, shayne will just woo the panties off the girlies, and journey south should headline a stage or too

Shayne is sheer brilliance on legs.
Journey South are good and likeable.
Andy is our new Nat King Cole - nothing wrong in that.
I voted for Shayne in this poll.

Shaynes got the best voice but I fear his attitude and lack of personality will be his downfall.

JS will probably nick it but I'd really like to see Andy win it. I love to see the underdogs come up trumps.

Journey South boys for me too

I didnt like Andy using the kids last week. They looked very uncomfortable and when the cameras showed Andy returnign to his home on 24/7 it looked like they didnt give a toss. I wonder how much of a family man Andy really is.

I think judging by the kids' reactions at the criticisms Andy has been getting, particularly the little boy last week when he misunderstood the judges saying it was Andy's last performance, we can safely say his kids more than care about him.

Casting aspertions on the life and parenting skills of someone you don't even know is an exremely low level to sink to.

Double post

I dont really care any more to be honest, but voted Andy

I do think Andy's kids care about him.

On 24/7, when it showing him going home, I got the impression that they see him quite often. Andy doesn't live far from the X-Factor house, so I'm assuming that he actually goes home a couple of times a week. That's probably why his kids weren't too over-excited.

Alright then, I'll change it so that if they come first, I'll definetly top myself *thumbs up*.

Journey South

You're not Brazilian by any chance?