well done shayne you saved me buying that record

it's a poor copy of andy's version

It's an awful song IMO, which i remember Sharon O sayin was her opinion on the first time it was played.

I preferred Andy's version, that song is not really Shayne.

It could have been written for Andy.

i would just like to point out somone who is very thick and nieve

someone on another thread said " i hope andy doesnt win now its not a good song for him "

HE WOULD HAVE SUNG MORE FRIGGIN SONGS THAN THAT ONE

FFS GROW UP

Merry Christmas.


It's not Bitter.....it's thms!!!

i'm not a bitter person, i prefer lager and red wine

and a very happy christmas to you qp
i'll pop in and wish a happy christmas
to all the ladies in the js thread in a mo

Bring the mistletoe.

Andy's version of the song was so good. Shayne's version was bland and lacked passion as per usual.

Andy showed talent by taking a song that seemed to be chosen for Shayne and singing it brilliantly and making it his own.

Plus the lyrics actually fit Andy's story... he added passion aswell.

Shayne sang it... and thats all he did, sing. Like reading a script for the first time... nothing in his voice really.

I certainly preferred Andy's version

I cant imagine Journey South singing it, in my opinion Shayne did it best even though I hate him.

Oh dear, well the song is just crap. It sounds like a rejected Westlife song.

was about to pop in when my phone rang
25 minutes of chat and no mention of the x-factor

the finalists dhould all have released the same single at the same time. . whoever got to number one - won tyhe x factor!! much fairer than all the phoneline voting full of prepubescent girls ringing for shayne and the over 18s voting for andy

I prefered Andy's version too BUT I have to buy it for my son otherwise he is going to moan me to death

What 3 different versions of the same awful song played over and over on the radio? Shoot the DJ!