• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • Dancing On Ice: All Stars
The Official ITV Ice Dancing Thread
<<
<
13 of 18
>>
>
topcat2
04-02-2006
not happy with that at all. How the heck can Kelly be in and John be out
bobblekat
04-02-2006
Originally Posted by topcat2:
“ not happy with that at all. How the heck can Kelly be in and John be out ”

Because the voting public are morons! John shouldn't have been in skate off!
flicker
04-02-2006
Aww shame. I'll just have to concentrate on watching him in the Musicals then.

Stefan is quite nice looking too.
AnnaNotherthing
04-02-2006
How did those two end up in the bottom two with someone like Kelly in there? She looked as stiff as my neck.
bob_loblaw
04-02-2006
Neither of them should have been in the bottom two. I hate shows where the public get a say in things.

Who on earth voted for Kelly Holmes? She really shouldn't be there. I feel so sorry for John he had a chance of winning and I think he loved every second of it.

Didn't want Stefan to go either though.
owllover
04-02-2006
I think Stefan was the best. He overcame his nerves whereas John was overwhelmed by his nerves. His wonderful flamboyance in the early shows had completely disappeared.
topcat2
04-02-2006
And the only reason David got through was two weeks of sympathy vote too.
strawberry66
04-02-2006
Tempted to start a thread

"Why an American/Canadian will never win a British reality show"
owllover
04-02-2006
That Kelly is still there is a travesty. She may be a wonder on the track but she looks like a drag artist on the ice.
Ferrari355
04-02-2006
Must admit that I dont know anything about ice skating, but I can tell what is entertaining and what isnt.

Can someone please explain to me how come John and Stefan can be in the bottom two, but "double gold medallist blah, blah, blah, Kelly Holmes" can go through?????

This is ridiculous.

(i've had my rant now so I'll leave you in peace!)
topcat2
04-02-2006
Originally Posted by strawberry66:
“Tempted to start a thread

"Why an American/Canadian will never win a British reality show" ”

do it do it lol

I love him I am so pissed off I'm not watching it next week. ANnoying Gaynor will probably win.
bobblekat
04-02-2006
It doesn't help that Jason keeps 'insulting' Kelly (though he is right!), it appeals to the public to vote for her just to get back on him... "How dare he insult Dame Kelly Holmes, double gold medallist". It is as if no one dares anymore to say anything negative about her, since she is some sort of national treasure... but she still lacks elegance, the lines, the grace to be a skater. It is very flippin simple... grrrrrrrrr.
mindyann
04-02-2006
That was just wrong!
I think that for Stefan to be in the bottom 2 for 3 weeks on the trot says that he is a) not getting the scores initially from the judges and b) not then getting the phone votes from the public on a regular basis.
What's the betting he's there again next week?
Live82005
04-02-2006
Originally Posted by topcat2:
“And the only reason David got through was two weeks of sympathy vote too.”

Never has a truer comment be made. I'm furious. The bottom two should have been Kelly and David. I can't believe John went!
owllover
04-02-2006
Originally Posted by bobblekat:
“It is as if no one dares anymore to say anything negative about her, since she is some sort of national treasure... but she still lacks elegance, the lines, the grace to be a skater. It is very flippin simple... grrrrrrrrr.”

Sums it up for me.
topcat2
04-02-2006
Exactly hes just not that good. He was ok tonight but the public want him gone. John was top last week
claire2281
04-02-2006
I'm not surprised by the stupid result from the puplic - having watched 3 series of SCD I'm used to that and it doesn't surprise me anymore.

What I am surprised by is the judges. Do they need a trip to spec savers? John was clearly more talented and would bring more to the competition than Stefan. To me it was a no brainer.

I'm not surprised that John looks pretty unhappy on ITV2 right now.

You'd think those that you could rely on to choose the best skaters would be the judges of all people. I'm not particularly thrilled about watching the rest of this series now. What's the point when something this ridiculous can happen?
Thriller
04-02-2006
Dear dear me, the British public do it again!

John was one of the best contestants in it and he's out in the fourth week?! I don't completely blame the judges because tonight Stefan's final performance was technically better than John's final performance but come on - he's been bottom two for three weeks now, surely his time is up? Anyway, as if John, an American, was going to win a British TV show?

Who are the idiots voting for Kelly Holmes? She's turning into the Chico of the competition! I actually think a lot of people's votes are formed by the music they dance to as well. "Believe" by Cher is a lot more energetic and exciting than "Suspicious Minds".
Julie J
04-02-2006
I'm not going to watch any more, John was robbed.
Kelly Holmes is only getting through because she's a double gold medallist nothing to do with her skating (very bad skating it is too).

It's a skating competition not vote on who you feel sorry for etc.

(That's my rant over)
topcat2
04-02-2006
Its just crappy. Bonnie is great in the air but shes a dancer so shes going to be. Her actual skating isn't that wonderful and its far easier for the women because they don't have to actually do the lifts and have the same balance. Kelly is useless, David really isnt that great, Stefan is quite soulless and lets face it Sean is probably going to go soon because of the lifts too and hes one of the only other decent ones.
bob_loblaw
04-02-2006
What happened to the geordie lass and him who wears lots of make up from blue?

Did they get the sack for being so very bad at presenting?
flicker
04-02-2006
At the end of the day, the person who normally wins this type of reality show where a skill of some kind is involved (not like BB for instance) is the person who has the most fans/is the most popular, not the one who does the best at the subject.
StevieBoo
04-02-2006
Originally Posted by Thriller:
“Dear dear me, the British public do it again!

John was one of the best contestants in it and he's out in the fourth week?! I don't completely blame the judges because tonight Stefan's final performance was technically better than John's final performance but come on - he's been bottom two for three weeks now, surely his time is up? Anyway, as if John, an American, was going to win a British TV show?

Who are the idiots voting for Kelly Holmes? She's turning into the Chico of the competition! I actually think a lot of people's votes are formed by the music they dance to as well. "Believe" by Cher is a lot more energetic and exciting than "Suspicious Minds".”


So agree with you!! nothing more to add you said it all.
topcat2
04-02-2006
Originally Posted by bob_loblaw:
“What happened to the geordie lass and him who wears lots of make up from blue?

Did they get the sack for being so very bad at presenting?”

Is that ITV2? I can't get freeview here even though I have a box. Its so annoying!!
owllover
04-02-2006
Originally Posted by Thriller:
“
Who are the idiots voting for Kelly Holmes? She's turning into the Chico of the competition! I actually think a lot of people's votes are formed by the music they dance to as well. "Believe" by Cher is a lot more energetic and exciting than "Suspicious Minds".”

I've wondered about the music too.

My only criticism of her is that she appears to gave adopted an attitude of "I'm me, Dame Kelly so don't say I'm no good".

News for you Kelly - You're second to none in athletics but you're an effing ugly mover.
<<
<
13 of 18
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map