i know i know this is a bb3 forum but i just i have to ask both of these shows have been popular but between bb3 and pop idol which one is the best in your opinion.

In my opinion even though the producers messed it up bb3 still made it for me and as for Pop idol well it was good when its was on but lets be truthfull here now i cant even remmber most of the contestant names and i wasn't that adicted.

Also plus itv soooo overhyped pop idol so much by saying its the tv event of the year. Well i bet itv r now well pissed off that bb has once again stole the lime light. Remmber that little programme called popstars that was overhyped as well but then came bb2 and it was all over. awwww

roll on bb4 i say

pop stars/idol stunk. just another excuse for overblown d-list celebs and producers to humiliate and exploit the desperate! bb is quality

I thought Pop Idol was good through the audition process but then grew quite boring once they started the shows in front of a live audience, apart from the final show which was fairly interesting.

how can you ask such a question??? lol

Because of the constant coverage it is very easy to get addicted to bb while I don't think you can be addicted to pop idol, at least not in the same way. Plus I think bb is far, far more entertaining.

Couldn't get into Pop Idol. The fact that the main show is on on a Saturday evening doesn't help either. BB is the original reality TV show and will NEVER be beaten.

I kind of understand how non BB fans feel now, because when I see these Pop idol ***** all over the TV it really annoys me.

i think that also goes to some of the other bb3 contestants as well but i agree

Simon Cowell and Pete Waterman were the true stars of Pop Idol.