• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Big Brother
Does anyone else feel that the wrong person won?
<<
<
3 of 8
>>
>
Grahame
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by emzi restalez
[
I really hoped a smart, attractive, strong woman would have won Big Brother. Instead an unnaturally thin, outdated ladette who thinks throwing bags of Pork Scratchings at anyone who weighs more than she does is funny has grabbed the crown. [/b]”

Interesting - most non-voting, shall we say 'more mature' OK older friends that I know were very anti Kate because of what they believed she represented.
Alrightmate
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by cerberus
hazzers, to an extent I agree with you, but if a staff member is going to post on the forums in an unofficial basis, then I think it would be better if they didn't have the staff ID under their username. Site owners/ moderators excepted.

Emzi, I have to say I find your attitude to some posters to be a little unreasonable. Maybe you should take a deep breath before you post.
”

What's wrong with Emzi having a view now?
BB3 has finished, he/she can't influence votes now.

Can't see what the problem is. I'm really interested to see what the moderators favourites were.
cerys
27-07-2002
Emzi - well said.

Maybe Endemol/C4 could have saved themselves some trouble by cutting out the middle man (Kate) and just chucked £70k down the toilet, where most of it will end up anyway.

Ooops, sorry, that was uncalled for. But hey, who cares?
oldgit
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by Grahame


OK she won and good luck to her. However if she got 30$ of the vote there are still 70% who preferred someone else. Lot of people.
”

Well thats how the first past the post rule works (unpopular governments have traded on it for years) the alternative is that they could have formed a coalition winners party and then they could have voted someone to be the winner every third Wednesday Hope Kate enjoys her year in office (still trying to find the smilies cos, I'm not having a serious dig)
mromega
27-07-2002
I'm going to say it again, personal attacks WILL NOT be tolerated

Forum members are all allowed to state their opinion BUT they should not be attacked personally for the opinions they have.

And perhaps some people should gather a bit more perspective on the whole Big Brother thing. It's a gameshow and the housemates should not be considered as role models in my opinion.

mromega
Board Moderator
Digital Spy Ltd
alexi
27-07-2002
For me there were only two winners tonight.......Jade for her unstoppable enthusiasm...and Alex for his humility...but there is only one with true charisma....ALEX
fallyhag
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by Alrightmate


What's wrong with Emzi having a view now?
BB3 has finished, he/she can't influence votes now.

Can't see what the problem is. I'm really interested to see what the moderators favourites were.
”


What I find annoying is that these people, reporters and Moderators, have been placed in a position of responsibilty within this forum. In that role they have had to take the high ground and censor etc...

Yes they can have a view, but not under the log in title that shows that status. Why? Coz such immature views such as Emzi really pisses me off after the numerous times I have been lectured to by these people.

Nobody likes a hypocrite!
loobyloo
27-07-2002
Quote:
“ quote:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by loobyloo
It was all such an anti climax. When Jade was first out, we knew something wasn't right - the sight of jonny and kate in there as the last two was gutting. Still, I predict we will see a lot more of alex and jade than the other two idiots. I know it sounds bitter, but I feel a bit cheated tonight. And what exactly was kate wearing - she looked like she had wet herself.
------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sour grapes eh? I bet you feel cheated... all those re-dials at 25p per shot... and what you got for it? Just what most people have already known, you can't go on looks, you have to open your eyes and see the personality and not be blinkered.

One day, you will open your eyes, and you will regret the words you have posted here as pitiful.

.”


Erm... no I don't think so. You can't go on looks? What do you mean? Did I mention anything about looks in my post? Are you trying to put words into my mouth? I fear that you are the bitter one, mr boz lightyear. You unpleasant man.
cerberus
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by Alrightmate


What's wrong with Emzi having a view now?
BB3 has finished, he/she can't influence votes now.

Can't see what the problem is. I'm really interested to see what the moderators favourites were.
”

Sorry, guess I wasn't clear, there's no problem with her having a view, obviously. My point is that if a post is not in an 'offical' DS capacity, they should not have the staff ID under the username. It wouldn't have caused the argument in this thread that way.
fallyhag
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by mromega
I'm going to say it again, personal attacks WILL NOT be tolerated

Forum members are all allowed to state their opinion BUT they should not be attacked personally for the opinions they have.

And perhaps some people should gather a bit more perspective on the whole Big Brother thing. It's a gameshow and the housemates should not be considered as role models in my opinion.

mromega
Board Moderator
Digital Spy Ltd
”


Point proven
fallyhag
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by cerberus


Sorry, guess I wasn't clear, there's no problem with her having a view, obviously. My point is that if a post is not in an 'offical' DS capacity, they should not have the staff ID under the username. It wouldn't have caused the argument in this thread that way.
”


FULLY AGREE

Dont be so quick to respond Omega, it was obvious to me mate.
cath99
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by Little Ali
I find it weird, and somehow disheartening to know that some people think Kate isn't nice and that Jade is. ”

I couldn't agree more.

Quote:
“Originally posted by murphy8461
I totally agree with what you say.

I have been an Alex fan from Day 1 but can honestly say if Alex didn't win Jade was the next person I would have liked to see win......these 2 have beeen the most honest people in the house for weeks now.

And before anyone jumps on my back I am 37 years old with 4 children and feel Jonny & Kate did not set a good example to the youngsters of today.

”

So you think that a good example for your kids would be somebody who is ignorant, bitchy, and a bully?
You'd rather your kids take their example of a deserving winner from somebody who the nation laughs at rather than with? You want them to emulate (that's what role models are for) somebody who shouts over others, is unintelligent, bitchy and rude.
What a shame.
Dipsy
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by emzi restalez
After watching the housemates full-time for all 9 weeks as a DS:BB reporter, I personally feel gutted that Kate won. The ex-performing arts student

I don't really think Drama A level makes you a "performing arts student".

doesn't need the money for a start (It's been hard not to say anything but one of my mates worked with Kate in London and she frequently bragged about being so wealthy that she didn't have to work).

So rich that she has a large loan to repay on her car.

Also - the fact that she was quite happy to puke everywhere

And your proof that she was "happy" about this? She was actually one of several who threw up during the series.

Instead an unnaturally thin

How does that tally with the fat arse jibes? She was hardly unnaturally thin. Indeed I would have thought that Sophie, Sunita and Alex were all thinner for their height.

outdated ladette

Which means what?

throwing bags of Pork Scratchings at anyone who weighs more than she does is funny ”

You just didn't understand the reference did you?


Are you really sure you are cut out be a DS reporter? You seem to lack the accuracy and unbiased perspective of your colleagues.
agentz
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by mromega
I'm going to say it again, personal attacks WILL NOT be tolerated

Forum members are all allowed to state their opinion BUT they should not be attacked personally for the opinions they have.

And perhaps some people should gather a bit more perspective on the whole Big Brother thing. It's a gameshow and the housemates should not be considered as role models in my opinion.

mromega
Board Moderator
Digital Spy Ltd
”

Sorry, but if you feel this thread is degenerating into personal attacks then why don't you close it? You have the power to do so. Or are you worried about offending another member of DS staff?
fandango
27-07-2002
I think the wrong person won, but I guess if you have acted all the way through , it must go in your favour.......performing arts etc.

Sadly it said it all when Davina appeared wearing her YES necklace.....Kate's most annoying saying.

Did not want to think they would try to sway it, but it appeared to work.

I was trying to vote for Jade for ages but it was constantly engaged......which I thought was a good sign......but could it have been intentional.....YOU DECIDE.
Mesostim
27-07-2002
This is entirely my own opinion. I don't expect anyone to agree with me. Nor do I expect to change anyones mind. In my view she was the the least contoversial winner. She was also the most boring winner. She didn't really excell in any way and her best best highlighted the lack of them. She relied on others to prop her up and never seemed to make an imapact herslf. Yessss! Yessss! Thats how I'll remember her. That's it really. No knocking her, if that's what it takes to win (and that matters) fine but she's down there with Criag when it comes to "winners" with me................
johnno
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by alexi
For me there were only two winners tonight.......Jade for her unstoppable enthusiasm...and Alex for his humility...but there is only one with true charisma....ALEX ”

I'll run with that. I can't explain why Kate and Jonny were the last 2 in the house, but the real star was self evident, and he will have the last laff, and good luck to the bloke. Kate will continue to have her fan base with the lads and ladettes no doubt for a short time, but how long can you sustain a career based on arsing about and getting drunk?
pistachio
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by cath99


I couldn't agree more.



So you think that a good example for your kids would be somebody who is ignorant, bitchy, and a bully?
You'd rather your kids take their example of a deserving winner from somebody who the nation laughs at rather than with? You want them to emulate (that's what role models are for) somebody who shouts over others, is unintelligent, bitchy and rude.
What a shame.
”



[SIZE=3]GO CATH99[/SIZE]
you tell them!
Jade did not deserve to win!
Straker
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by emzi restalez


Take your own advice and move on...to another forum.
”


More impartiality. I’ll miss reading your totally unbiased reporting.


(NOT) loving your work.
mromega
27-07-2002
I'm trying to keep this thread open.

All the mods have too much to do tonight moderating the mass of posts that are being made therefore we are likely to take any action against any problem members when it is a bit quieter.

The question about different login's can be answered thus :- Only one login is allowed per person, this even applies to DS Staff. Even if DS staff had different logins it would be easy to match up one with another and make the same accusations. Therefore unless signed in a similar style to below, posts are personal opinion.

mromega
Board Moderator
Digital Spy Ltd
Grahame
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by oldgit


Well thats how the first past the post rule works (unpopular governments have traded on it for years) the alternative is that they could have formed a coalition winners party and then they could have voted someone to be the winner every third Wednesday Hope Kate enjoys her year in office (still trying to find the smilies cos, I'm not having a serious dig)
”

Neither was I and I've been around long enough to have seen quite a lot of those unpopular governments as well. Just a thought - personally I think Kate and Jonny being in the first two is no surprise. Their in house alliance was probably replicated by a number of voters also. Jade and Alex were individual candidates. Still thats the way it goes.
cerberus
27-07-2002
Quote:
“Originally posted by mromega
I'm going to say it again, personal attacks WILL NOT be tolerated

Forum members are all allowed to state their opinion BUT they should not be attacked personally for the opinions they have.

And perhaps some people should gather a bit more perspective on the whole Big Brother thing. It's a gameshow and the housemates should not be considered as role models in my opinion.

mromega
Board Moderator
Digital Spy Ltd
”

Don't be so naïve about things mromega, of course the housemates are role models, all celebrities are role models to smaller or larger extents. It is a fact that many people will look up to celebrities as a role model of how to act, things to do etc. Maybe you wouldn't consider them to be role models, but that doesn't mean that they are not.

Also, yes maybe some people should gather perspective, but that doesn't mean that their views are invalid.

If you feel the thread has degenerated, why bother with a second warning, you seem to be shutting threads all over the place tonight, why not add another to the tally...
discoboy
27-07-2002
The right person won accept it!

She's a natural all rounder I don't care if people think she's dated she is just herslef and not too shallow to show it. i personally thought she looked like a very contemporary person not like all you shallow ****ers who change like the seasons.
LadyKnight
27-07-2002
Why is it people want to drag their children into this argument.

There was a totally offensive thread posted today about children having role models from the BB3 house. It was the worst thing I had ever read in here.

Why are children watching BB3 anyway? If they are - its ok for one person to get drunk and throw up but not another?
Its ok for one woman to kiss another woman while they are both in bed with a man. But its not ok for someone else who really likes the person (in hand) to give a handjob?

Hmmm strange bloody world we live in.

Why don't we keep the children out of this and just speak for ourselves.

LK - would hope its not too much to ask for.
cerys
27-07-2002
The winner and runner-up of BB3:

http://www.channel4.com/apps3/bigbro...y.jsp?id=14874

<<
<
3 of 8
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map