Dear DSF posters,

Yes me again! I am not turning the DS Board into the Bonnie Board but it is interesting!

So here is the question:

If Bonnie did very very well ON the ice next week, would you vote for her based on the performance, after all as Nicky said, people should be voting on the day's performance.

Simplay answers of Yes and No with up to 30 words of why? Just a quickie to get the opinions up for Saturday!

Good Luck
James x

PS - Again, Podge1 keep it near the top. Thanx! LOL!

Yes (if I were voting which I'm not), if she gave the best performance on the ice of the evening she would deserve the votes

yes i would give her one vote if she did the best performance and actually SKATED but i would also have to vote for stefan aswel as im behind him all the way

No, because I don't believe she deserves to be there.

no no james - only one bonnie thread at a time near the top.

I agree gaynor and stevan desrve it more than Bonnie and both improve the most

Yes, but then i'm voting for her no matter what as i believe she deserves to be there as much as anyone.

Playing devils advocate here....Lil Miss Blonde will vote for Stefan no matter what and you will vote for Bonnie no matter what...so even if they fall over (god forbid) or make a total pigs ear of their routines... is there any point in them skating at all?...this is just a question I'm not trying to bait anyone or anything I'm just curious to know

The votes should go to the best skater on the night regardless of who you're personal fav is.

I'll be voting for Stefan. At this stage I think they've all proved they can skate, so I'm just voting for my favourite!

I think you could be right

Bonnie could skate like an Olympic champion and she would not get votes

But she would get respect...for most people it's not just the razzle dazzle and entertainment that counts most people want to see a bit of skill thrown in too so she needs to entertain and convince people she CAN skate

Yes but if she does skate like a champion would you vote for her over Stefan or would you vote for Stefan no matter what, even if he didn't skate particularly well (say he had a bad day)...would the performance they give on the night count

No you're exactly right, i've supported Bonnie from the beginning and i'm not going to stop now, no matter what happens, and i doubt anyone else will either. That's why i'm sceptical of people coming forward and saying they will vote for Bonnie if she does a fantastic performance, 100% on the ice.

No I wouldn't vote for her. But I'd respect her more and if she won I'd hold my hands up and say well done. By the same token would all the Bonnie fans not vote her if she was poor?

No one is going to stop supporting their favourites at this stage...even if they don't deserve it on the night.

makes the idea of a final rather redundant then really

It's down to popularity now, i think.

Bit like the Big Brother final really

it all comes down to who appeals to the tweenies and house wives

basically a popularity contest, it has been for the last couple of weeks

YES. Irritating as she is, I would vote for her. I always vote on the performance on the night.

No, because I've liked Gaynor all the way through and I think she's the most improved... I also love hers and Daniel's partnership.

I'd also vote for Stefan over Bonnie because, again, he's been pretty consistent especially in the last couple of weeks - skating a LOT on his own without hold of Kristina.

not sure where i fit into this category - i'm neither a tweeny or a housewife!

Me neither...I think it's a sweeping generalisation. Some people think that if you vote for Stefan its because you fancy him

i abhor the personal remarks that have been made about bonnie. i'm not a fan of her performance because IMO she doesn't spend enough time on the ice.

However I think it completely out of order to comment on her face or to play guessing games about her age and elsewhere on this forum someone described gaynor as horseface.

wonder what these fms look like?

She looks nothing like Ruud Van Nistelrooy.