The answer is on Saturday's performance i dont think so, what do others think?
Did Georgina deseve to go?
If not this week, very soon. She may have a bit more difficulty with the other, can one say, sexier dances knowing what she has gone through with James
Possibly not - I think the dancers that show no or little improvement from week to week (possibly Jan) deserve to go more than those that show no signs of getting better.
Last edited by CaptainSensible : 30-10-2006 at 13:01
Last edited by CaptainSensible : 30-10-2006 at 13:01
Just wondering, Capt. Sensible, whether their partnership would have grown as much as her ballroom dancing did this week.
Yes. She did well, and I'm glad she left on a night where she could feel good about her performance and score, but I don't honestly think she could have improved much more. Especially in the latin dances.
She wasn't the worst on saturday bit it was right that she left. She went on a high. But Len's 8 was terrible, it wasn't that good.
In all fairness, probably no since she had shown improvement that Jan didn't but in a way it was probably best for her. At least this way she went on a high instead of getting a possible slating again this week.
Yeah she did deserve to go! She wasn't the worst on Sat but she's hardely been brilliant! And as we have seen the people at the bottom rarely go anyway! And most of the reason she had such a fab score was Lens ridiculous over marking! I really liked Georgie but I thik her time was up! Im glad she went out on a high though!
Not on saturdays performance and overall the 4 weeks probably Jan Ravens deserved to go more. 
BUT if she had stayed and Arlene had said next week she walked like a mongoloid or something there may have been a chance of losing more better dancers later on
BUT if she had stayed and Arlene had said next week she walked like a mongoloid or something there may have been a chance of losing more better dancers later on
not on the performance on the night, but as has already been said..it's history repeating..just like fiona
Not on Saturdays performance, it was far far better to anything they have done before. Peter was b****y awful and should ON THAT PERFORMANCE have gone.
BUT on the whole series she had to go PDQ, maybe it was kinder to get rid of her now instead of putting through another week of verbal abuse from wotshisface and suffer the indignity of moving round the dance floor like a one legged drunk.
Hopefully Peter and Erin will get the message and put together something better next time.
BUT on the whole series she had to go PDQ, maybe it was kinder to get rid of her now instead of putting through another week of verbal abuse from wotshisface and suffer the indignity of moving round the dance floor like a one legged drunk.
Hopefully Peter and Erin will get the message and put together something better next time.
I'm not sure anyone deserves to go - they all seem to put in a lot of effort and time.
Georgina did look relived to go thou (and so would I if the alternative was to spend another week training with James!!)
Georgina did look relived to go thou (and so would I if the alternative was to spend another week training with James!!)
I don't think she did, based on Saturdays performance she shouldn't have gone and looking at the past few weeks it should have been Jan. Between her and Anton they have made a mess of all of their dances.
Georgina should have been given another week for her improvement.
Georgina should have been given another week for her improvement.
No! It should've been Jan, both on dancing ability, and irritation factor. 
Georgina danced well in the Foxtrot, and she came across as a bubbly character, she was improving, Jan is not!
Georgina danced well in the Foxtrot, and she came across as a bubbly character, she was improving, Jan is not!
Originally Posted by PrincessNidor:
“I'm not sure anyone deserves to go - they all seem to put in a lot of effort and time.
Georgina did look relived to go thou (and so would I if the alternative was to spend another week training with James!!)”
“I'm not sure anyone deserves to go - they all seem to put in a lot of effort and time.
Georgina did look relived to go thou (and so would I if the alternative was to spend another week training with James!!)”
Not 100% sure about that
we will see the body language and the gap on the sofa this evening
i agree with peachUK i think james was horrible to her when he said ''its not rocket science''. i know how difficult it is to pick up dances in a short space of time as i do dancing at school (its not ballroom dancing though!!!), but i think its good that she left with her highest score!
i think Georgina had a ball on saturday and it showed in her performance, she was happy smiling and quite competetent, even the judges said what an improvement from last week. Im not so sure that she really did want to leave she seemed to be enjoying erself at last, Jan should have gone or Peter.
Based on Saturday night's performance NO. I think Georgina was better on the night than Jan, and showed more improvement.
Originally Posted by stargirl 2:
“i think Georgina had a ball on saturday and it showed in her performance, she was happy smiling and quite competetent, even the judges said what an improvement from last week. Im not so sure that she really did want to leave she seemed to be enjoying erself at last, Jan should have gone or Peter.”
“i think Georgina had a ball on saturday and it showed in her performance, she was happy smiling and quite competetent, even the judges said what an improvement from last week. Im not so sure that she really did want to leave she seemed to be enjoying erself at last, Jan should have gone or Peter.”
Peter shouldn't have gone because he did do a great waltz and tango.
But Georgina shouldn't have gone because it was a very competent performance and showed great improvement (although it was good she went out on a personal high).
So basically Jan and Anton should have gone... and if they don't go this week i'll be annoyed
