Best: Ray and Camilla.
Can't bring myself to vote for Mark & Karen - it was the best but they were so off at the beginning of the first attempt that we'll never know if they would have got it together.

Worst: Claire & Brendan (a real shame)
Voted For: Carol and Matthew
Surprised by: Jan and Anton's beautiful ending.

We remarked on this whilst they were dancing...it was a bit like Ola and Spoony way back in week one...not in the sense that Lilia didn't give Matt enough to do but she's so shiny and your attention is sort of naturally drawn to her!

Best Salsa - Mark & Karen
Best Waltz - Ray & Camillia
Worst - Matt & Lilkia
Surprised with - Louisa & Vincent / Claire & Brendan
Vote For - Mark & Karen
Last edited by bgrules99 : 04-11-2006 at 19:55

Best: Mark and Karen, Carol and Matt, Ray and Camilla - I know it's three couples but I can't seperate them and hey..i'm greedy!
Worst: Claire and Brendan - couldn't watch after about 30 secs
Voted for: Carol and Matt
Surprised by: Karen stopping and demanding to start again..she had a point, but it still shocked me. Also surprised I agreed with most of the judges scores for the first time since series 2. Finally I thought Louisa and vincent would be heaps better!

Small point but Karen didnt ask, Mark did.

Best : Ray & Camilla and Mark & Karen
Worst : Louisa and Vincent - it was all a bit nothingy
Vote: none. The people who deserve to be safe are.
Surprised with: Even before Mark & Karen's microphone tangle happened, their first attempt wasn't especially good - but the second time round it was so much better, really good. Not so much surprising as odd, i suppose. Also, the editting of Brendan surprised me, seemed to be done to stir up trouble.

Best- Carol and Matthew
Worst- Claire and Brendan
Voted- Carol and Matthew
Suprised- Jan and Anton being pretty ok

Best: Ray and Camilla/Peter and Erin (followed by Mark and Karen, Carol and Matthew)
Worst: Matt and Lilia/Claire and Brendan
Voted: Carol and Mark
Suprised with: Mic-gate and let's wind up Brendan-gate.
Last edited by Jocko Homo : 04-11-2006 at 20:25

cmrxx - sorry my mistake!x

Best - Mark/Karen Ray and Camilla
Worst - Claire and Brendan
Vote - Peter and Erin
surprised with Karen and Mark stopping - Marks 1st attempt wasnt great

Best- Mark and Karen
Worst - Claire and Brendan
Vote- Mark and Karen
Surprised with - the BBC trying to wind Brendan up, naughty Tess!

Also scared by how many people are saying that Mark and Karen were best but they aren't voting for them! Please do cos they could go out

Which pair was the best ? would love to say mark and karen but as they had two 'go's' and the second was better shall say peter and erin
Which pair was the worst tonight? brenda and claire. or matt and lillia.
Which pair/pairs would you vote for? mark and karen, claire and matthew, peter and erin
Suprised with? janton. they were good tonight. surprised they went but it is so often the case that when somebody finally does well, they go

why is no one voting lillia the worst with matt! that samba was terrible!

Lots of people (myself included) thought Matt & Lilia were as bad as Brendan & Claire - you need to take your Brendan coloured specs off.

Best - Ray and Camillia, Carol and Matt, Mark and Karen (brought down a little because the first go was a bit ropey)

Worst - Claire and Brendan

Voted - Carol and Matthew

Surprised by: Brendan having the audacity to say that the judges marked them down only because of last week when he has previously been admirable honest about their performance. Arlene only giving Carol a 6. The crowd boos...

Best: Ray & Camilla
Worst: Jan & Anton (but I'm going to watch again to check)
Voted: Ray & Camilla and Brendan & Claire (Oh...and Louisa & Vincent by accident!!!!)
Surprised: Peter & Erin. I thought they did a good job.

I didn't think Brendan & Claire got a fair chance having to change their routine at short notice when they'd already toned it down earlier in the week. Their training footage looked amazing and none of that was in tonight's performance.. I think the situation is highly suspect but I've given my views in 'Brendan' thread.
Last edited by PeachUK : 04-11-2006 at 22:19

The speaker behind The "red Button" totally disagreed a lot of times with the comment of the "real judges"

Phillip Jackson gives a nice comment of the routines and what went wrong and what was excellent.

I did believe him more then "The Unbelieveble Four"


Best: Mark-Karen followed close bij Ray-Camilla
then Lovely scottish flower Carol-matt
Worst: sorry Jan and Dude Du Beke

Best: Mark and Karen - amazing. And although I agree the first time round didn't look as good (we'll never know how it would've gone) I'm seriously impressed at how Mark just went for it all out 2nd time round. In that situation many people would fall apart but it was just incredible!

Worst: Claire and Brendan - sorry. I'm sure there are reasons and it stinks that they've apparently been messed about, but _to me_ it was embarassing to watch it looked that awful (don't claim to know owt about salsa, but it was just not good (friend Linda says "cringeworthy")

Voted: Mark and Karen, Carol and Matt

Surprised by: Carol was, IMO, really good tonight, and I didn't think the judges marks reflected how good

Best Emma and Darren
Worst Claire and Brendon
Voted Matt and Lilia

Surprised Claire and Brendon are still in

Best: Carol & Matthew for Salsa (Mark & Karen close but re-start put me off them), Ray & Camilla for VW

Worst: Matt & Lilia for Salsa, Jan & Anton for VW (but just because the others were better, not because they were rubbish)

Voted: Carol & Matthew, Peter & Erin

Surprised: That Arlene criticised Vincent

BEST Ray & Camilla , Carol & Matthew, Karen and Mark. I can't seperate any of these three.

WORST Brendan & Claire / Matt and Lillia
I'm not sure if the BBC forcing a cut in Brendan & Claire's dance affected what we would have seen. Matt was wooden.

VOTED Jan & Anton

SURPRISED Jan & Anton a real improvement and I felt that Craigs comments didn't reflect his scoring (again)
Last edited by carolinelise : 04-11-2006 at 23:50

Best: Mark and Karen by a mile - I didn't think I could love them anymore but wow they pulled out such a performance - all the more so because of the mike problem.

Worst: Brendan and Claire

Voted: Mark and Karen plus threw one vote to Brendan and Claire as an anti judge vote as much as anything. Plus can still see potential in them.

Surprised: Arlene comments to and about Matthew confused me and seemed out of order.

Best: Mark and Karen
worst: Brendan and Claire (not Claire's fault, but there you go) and Jan and Anton.
Voted for: Mark and Karen

Surprised by: Jan's sore loser comments to the judges. Very bad sport I thought and I wonder who she thought should have gone if not her. The only couple that were worst on the night were Brendan and Claire imo and on other nights they have been better.

Best: Mark & Karen (Wow, I thought they were amazing, 2nd chance or not)

Worst: No really atrocious routine for me - but I did cringe at Matt's gyrating and Claire's posing.

Vote: I don't. (At least, not yet)

Surprised: By Jan's very bitter riposte to Craig when voted out. Plus Claire & Brendan weren't as raunchy & sexy as I expected (or as they had been previously)

When Arlene was talking to Carol about Matt, she was talking about Matt Dawson...Matthew was just joking when he pointed to himself. It's all a bit confusing with the similar names and if you were talking about Matt Dawson and I've misunderstood I'm V Sorry and just ignore me!!