So who's buying their new Best Of? Have to say it's a very odd tracklist with a few forgettable B-sides and no new song to promote it. Still, I'll be there first day, the moron that I am.

Here's two pro reviews:

Mansized

Stylus

Pointless. It shouldn't be called 'Stop The Clocks' it should be called 'Contractual Obligation'.

to be fair to Oasis, they have stated that they arnt pleased to be releasing a greatest hits yet..but have no choice but to go along with it.

Who picked the songs? Was it oasis or the record company?

I think it its a bit of both, Oasis and their record company came to an agreement on the album, there was originally gonnabe 2 new tracks, but Oasis didn't want want them on it. I could be wrong though.

Oasis im led to beleive, theyve said they wanted to make it a "greatest set list" album

ie if they played their best gig ever it'd have those songs in it

and they said that they plan on doing a chronologcal 'proper' best of when their careers are over.

Yeah, it says in that Mansized review that Oasis chose the tracklist.

I think it's an excellent tracklisting but should have a few more tracks on. It's a double CD but only lasts 86 mins - you can fit nearly double this onto 2 CDs so there's no reason for missing off classics like "Whatever" or "Stop Crying...".