was such joy, the only compensation was that the truly heinous Peter(although thoroughly entertaining and good sport)went.

The Judges baised comments about Emma should now stop, she can't dance, she is inelegant, Woopie Goldbergs walk from the bank in Ghost is more elegant than Emma Bunting. Please bin her next week, I'll give £100 to any charity if you remove her face from the screens next week.

regardless of what you think about her and the judges, to say she can't dance is a bit silly.

I'm not an Emma fan but she can dance. Just not as well as the judges make out.

er excuse me, didn't the judges pan her this week, get lost and come back when you actually know something about dancing!!!

DerChef says


All this "Bitchy and scratchy" show makes me send a few votes more votes her way every week


Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Yeah

I think quite a lot of the celebs would take a 'panning' like that - especially if a '9' was the result!

and you shouldn't back until you've put all of your toys back into your pram...

Thank you for your in-depth and professional opinion. Indeed, you know bugger all about dancing.

Well Bruno has been the judge who dislikes Emma the most and as for you CS, i don't have toys, I have opinions!!

Emma is nothing better than average.

Anyway, good result tonight.

The most undeserved 9 in the history of the show - i'm not in the least surprised it earned her her much deserved place in the bottom 2, her Cha Cha was crap, Carol's much better and yet they had the same marks.

Wasn't sorry to see her there and hoped she would go over gentle Schmeichel
Last edited by Mrs Harman : 18-11-2006 at 22:35

I am definitly not an Emma fan (but a huge Darren fan ), but i can see she has some dancing ability. I don't believe for a minute she is anywhere near as good as other people in the competition and i do think its obvious that sometimes she gets over marked for some seriously average performances. I did want her to go out tonight and i am hoping she does go next week or at least before the final because i believe there are people who deserve to be in the final more than Emma.

well I agree maybe it warranted and eight but then again I don't think louisa's jive warranted a ten either. (think jill and darren here)

Also Carole and Matt were better than last week, but were weaker if not equally as weak then darren and emma

Give it a break, another opportunity to have a dig at Emma. I voted like crazy tonight and I am so angry they where in the bottom too. They where not the weakest couple so didn’t deserve to be in the bottom 2. Mark and Karen or Claire and Brendan should of gone not Erin and Peter.

I think it brings it home when, having just seen the Jill/Darren jive this week again and the memory is fresh that it only scored 8's and 9's on the first outing. I know you can't really compare dances from different series but it was just interesting to see how the scoring has altered in the meantime.

thankyou some flippin sane comment at last!!

She has admitted herself that she can't dance, she was dreadful tonight.
So me and all the other people who didn't vote for her tonight are idiots then? She is dreadful, her suppoosed sexy little moves(tacky) can be seen being performed by lots of little trollops like her in most clubs on friday and saturday night's.

I really have never liked carol Smilie or Claire but I have to say they entertaining and they try and don't rely on being part of the most shite trashy pop group ever invented.

Really it was only one judge that overmarked her and Bruno is never the most reliable scorer.
She's suffering from dancing first

No axe to grind here, honestly, but just about every week this series you could say that at least one of the bottom 2 didn't 'deserve' to be there or were technically not the weakest couple.

Emma's technique was better than Carols but the routine was not. Carol still has not nailed the technical aspects of the dance like Emma. The marks took both these factors into account.

So, I presume you vote on personality rather than dancing talent with your 'gentle Schmiechel' comment. If Ghandi was in the competion he would get your vote everytime then.

She danced first last week if i'm not mistaken and she did well, so whats the difference?

Emma's problem is that she can 'Dance' generally but she can't dance (or doesn't put the effort in to dance) a Cha Cha or a foxtrot, if that makes any sense. She can get away (sometimes) with rubbish footwork because she has naturally good lines etc. but it cought up with her tonight.

Peter made mistakes this week and last week. He has the least dancing talent. Mark lacked the intimacy required for a rumba but nailed the technique. Claire had the passion and sexiness but possibly, from Len's point of view, did not have the lines. But as Craig said she had I would believe him.

There is no way in this world that Peter would ever be, or has ever been, as good a dancer as either Mark or Claire...unless they were dead and I would ask for a recount.

week after week louisa dances one of the last and i think its only one week where she has been one of the forst to dance, whereas emma has danced first twice, and twice been panned by the judges, its no wonder she is hated by all the cinics

The couple I didnt like tonight was Mark and Karen, they should of gone. Emma wasnt the best but i thought she was better than Carol, it was more fun and flirtatious