Would if bother you if Lilia won again?

3 of 3

xadie

26-11-2006

Originally Posted by bigtoe:
“Cant understand the fuss over Mark, his neck and shoulders were hunched and stiff. I think he was overmarked tonight, as was Emma.”

Originally Posted by Christian Cage:
“I think he was overmarked as well.”

Me three! I was so surprised to hear him getting universally praised, when he seemed stiff and jerky, not flowing, and seemed to be having real trouble keeping up with the dance, taking huge steps, everything in his posture from the middle to the end screaming 'I'm in trouble'! When I compare it to Matt or even Peter's ballroom from previous weeks I think it was pretty poor. What do I know, though, I certainly never choreographed Hot Gossip!

katie_p

26-11-2006

I''m not sure it was overmarked, I thought it was Mark's best performance in ballroom. I wish the judges would at least mention the fact that his hold needs some improvement. But his posture was definitely much better than in the training footage they showed on friday.

Gigglegirl89

26-11-2006

Originally Posted by c graham:
“no i wouldn't mind her winning with matt because he deserves it more that darren did last year i don't believe he should of own
matt is a far better dancer than he was so no i don't mind and lilia is good so why not”

I dont think this is true, i think darren was amazing last series, look at the freestyle he did in the final!!! That was phenomenal!!! Love Matt, but love Lilia more!!!

PrincessNidor

26-11-2006

I think Lilia is an excellent teacher and it would not bother me if she won again. The improvement is Matt is amazing and Lillia has really brought out the best in him.

I actually thought Louisa was undermarked tonight - she was much better than Emma or Mark. Her skills are really improving and she seems to be really enjoying it too.

rita1

26-11-2006

Originally Posted by Strictly Chris:
“As a big fan of Lillia, I must say it would not bother me if she & Matt reached the final, even though Lillia was in the final of the last series. It would just prove how good her teaching skills are, and I think it would be impractical not to allow professionals to win more than one final of the show.

However that said I can sympathise with the "she's had her turn" element, and I do feel that Anton, Camilla, Erin & Ian should reach the number 1 position. If you put restrictions on the number of times a professional could reach the final, well I think that would just demotivate them really, and make them less inclined to sign up to a series of SCD.

Christopher”

A very good point about the demotivation element Chris. After all it's a bit like saying Brazil shouldn't be allowed to win the World Cup, or (dare I say it!!) Australia the Ashes! The best man or woman should win, even if it's over and over again.
And wouldn't it be boring if we all knew the contest was really only between those that haven't already won, and we could discount the others.

rita1

26-11-2006

Originally Posted by Doghouse Riley:
“When are people going to realise that the majority of the public vote comes from the viewing public who know "naff all" about dance?
I'd think the votes for Matt are helped by the appeal of Lilia, as for the viewers, she is both attractive, has an excellent personaliy and is the best female professional dancer.
A lot of her consistently good performances will influence the public vote for Matt to some extent.”

I think what's helping Matt's vote is not Lilia but the fact that he is improving all the time. I believe the public enjoy seeing someone trying very hard and getting better as a result. In terms of improvement, the other contestants that are left are standing still in comparison to Matt (if not actually regressing sometimes).

Sloopy

26-11-2006

It doesn't matter to me which of the pro dancers wins - I just don't want it to be Matt! But if their partner is good enough, then I don't think it would matter if they won for a second time.

Chilli Dragon

26-11-2006

I would love it if Matt & Lilia won. I don't think there is anything wrong with the same pro winning - it shows how good a teacher she is.

Jana29

26-11-2006

Really don't want them to win. Couldn't stand Darren Gough and don't like Matt -Also don't think he's the best- have an increasing feeling that Louisa could win . So much as I think Lilia is brilliant with her partners I wouldn't be happy if she won again.

xcutie piex

26-11-2006

Originally Posted by Jana29:
“Really don't want them to win. Couldn't stand Darren Gough and don't like Matt -Also don't think he's the best- have an increasing feeling that Louisa could win . So much as I think Lilia is brilliant with her partners I wouldn't be happy if she won again.”

i like lilia as well but i really want louisa to win!!!!!!!

3 of 3