Series 3 - Kerry Katona
Series 4 - Joe Pasquale
Series 1 - Tony Blackburn
Series 6 - Matt Willis
Series 5 - Carol Thatcher
Series 2 - Phil Tufnell

Series 3. Absolute classic. Only Series 2 comes close.

Series 4 was utter tripe, and Series 5 wasn't much better. Series 6 was good, probably my third favourite.

I thought series 2 was the best - 'Just give us the bl**dy food!' That was brilliant, as well as watching Tuffers, Linda Barker and Anthony Worral-Thompson getting drunk all the time.

But my favourite winner has to be Carol Thatcher. She was brilliant.

Series 3 - Was so much fun I can even over look the most undeserving winner.

Series 5 - Loved Thatch

Series 6 - Really enjoyed this series too. Would've preffered Myleene or David or Jan to have won, but it had its talking points.

Series 1 - The original, good fun.

(BIG GAP)

Series 4 - The only reason this wasn't last was because of the immense JSP and the hilarious Paul Burrell

Series 2 - Undeserving winner, awful group of smug celebs. Tuffnell, AWT & The Barker were dreadful Fash attempted to carry this series, but he couldn't quite manage it alone.

mine would be

Serris 2
Serris 4
Serris 5 despite Carol Thatcher winning
Serris 3
Serris 1
Serris 6

I loved Series 2 when they all revolted and walked across the bridge and into the studio and confronted the producers over the food. Absolutely fantastic television.

Series 3 - Apart from the dreadful winner. Peter/Jordan and Lydon made the show for me.

Series 6 - Best for years. The Gest was the star of the show and such a surprise.

Series 1 - Original and fresh but with some really annoying contestants.

Series 5 - Bit too bland fro me. Just loats of nice people sitting round being nice. Thatch saved it being even duller.

Series 4 - Dull, dull, dull. Except JSP, I didn't care about any of them.

Series 2 - By a million miles the worst. I hated this lot. Crap celebs, smug tw*t of a winner. Fash was the only tiny redeeming feature imo. Wanted to slap the rest of them.

Series 1 - Uri Geller doing the food was priceless. Good worthy winner, but would have loved to have seen more of Nigel.

Series 2 - Focus, loved it when Tuffers got smashed also.

Series 6 - Would have been number 1, but for the fact the Mr "Shampoo and Body Lotion" didn't win it. Great series, shame about the result.

Series 5 - Best winner (of the lot) in a rather dull series.

Series 3 - Pretty dull, terrible winner.

Series 4 - Very dull, decent winner.

I'm very glad they have gone back to one series a year, I think the Joe Pasquale series was poorly recieved cause it came on so sooner after series 3 (which was dull).

didn't see the first two series...

personally, series 3 was the best, it had brockett, kerry, jennie, as well as peter/jordan...who i liked at the time

series 4 should have more votes than that, despite having a non-entity of a winner...paul burrell, sophie anderton, janet, natalie appleton were all great characters.

series 5 was probably the dullest...it was good, but there was NO conflict at all...it had its moments though.

series 6 has been very good

Only really liked series one and six.

The relationship in No 4 between Paul Burrell and Janet Street-Porter was my highlight of all the series. After that, I'd say No 6 was the best, thanks to Jan, Gest and Matt Willis. In third place, I'd put the insania of Jordan, Andre and Rotten, 3rd series. It's been said on many threads, but the eventual winners do not always make for the best memories.

Liked series 2 the best. Fash's focus and Wayne Sleep covered in waffles can still make me laugh. Yeah the 3 musketeers thing got a big smug - but I quite liked the general camp camaraderie.

Series 3 probably comes in next - Peter Andre, Jenny Bond & John Lydon all being stars in their own way.

Then series 6 - its been pretty good really.

Followed by series 4 - some decent comtestants, but a lot of dead wood in the likes of Ferguson, Fargas, Reeves and Sorrell etc.

Series 5 really was a poor effort, despite a good winner.

Didn't see series 1

I didn't see series 1 and 2. For me it's between 4 & 6 withthe latter shading it.

Series 3- Easily the best. Loads of great chracters. Kerry, Jordan, Peter, John, Lord Brockett and Jenny Bond.

Series 2- Also had good chracters with Tuffers, Fash, Worrall Thomson. Plus the sausage mutiny.

Series 5- OK, I only really remeber Carol Thatcher

Series 4 - Was on only a few months after series 3, so it suffered because that had been so good.

Series 6- Utter tosh, if it hadn't been for David I may have given up watching.

Didn't watch series 1.

In chronological order...

Season 3: Highly entertaining and produced the most stars/comebacks
Season 5: Without C Thatch, I wonder if we'd have had a sixth season...
Season 6: David Gest = absolute genius. How did they get him to take part? Offer him £1million?
Season 1: Fantastic for a debut. All four women were outstandingly entertaining.
Season 4: Janet Street-Porter = TV gold!
Season 2: Daniella, Wayne and Sian were they only celebrities I could tolerate...
Last edited by The Body : 04-12-2006 at 19:06

I knew a woman who voted for best of series on this show, and she died. No, she really did.

Series 3 - Kerry Katona

voted for series 4 only because of Natalie Appleton's classic madness which had me in stitches

Mine would go in this order:-

Series 3 - Loved the whole peter & jordan thing, Loved kerry and I just think it was a really good series.

Series 6 - Wel I suppose it's probably just because it's the most recent but I seemed to really get into this years!

Series 5 - Loved Sid Owen!! Lol and it was very entertaining with Carol Thatcher & Sheree Etc.

Series 4 - Briefly watched...

Series 1 & 2 - Didn't watch at all.

I did watch a bit of series 2 actually.. but I can't remember much of it
Except For Phil Tufnell Of Course
Last edited by elise..x : 05-12-2006 at 16:51

Kerry, Jordan and Pete has got to be the absolute OK magazine worst but I can understand why it would be popular here..

My personal favourite was the Phil Tufnell show for the simple inclusion of Fash the bash.

I'm somewhat surprised that series 6 is second in the poll given the number of posters who said it was boring.
Just negative people I guess.

Well theres hardly any point posting if you enjoy the series - only people that moan need to post really.

Could you explain that please?

I don't follow your reasoning.

Series 6 - Thought it had just the right mix of comedy and conflict. They all got on but they were still bitchy. Liked the fact that Matt winning was unexpected and thought he fully deserved it. David Gest was fantastic.

Series 3 - Entertaining, good mix of characters. Produced some of the most memorable I'm A Celeb contestants - but also some of the most forgettable. Pleasantly suprised by Jordan. Shame about the winner.

Series 5 - Carol's spirit was great. I liked the fact they all got on, but the series became tedious towards the end and lost momentum.

Series 4 - Too many people walking out too early. Natalie Appleton was annoying, as was Sophie Anderton. The Vic Reeves stunt fell flat. Joe and Paul and Janet were the only three memorable contestants.

Series 1 - It was good, but looking at how the show has developed, now it just seems to basic. The contestants from this series certainly seemed to have it slightly easier.

Series 2 - Bad group of contestants, too many ego's. Just plain boring.