O.K, here's a poll for you. I'm trying to ascertain who was the best and worst celeb dancer in all series of SCD. I'm going to put forward 10 names in each catergorie and I'd like you to rank them in order, 1 being the lowest mark, 10 the highest. On Wednesday I'll tally the votes and knock out the lowest scoring in each catergorie.

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker
Fiona Phillips
Carol Vorderman
David Dickinson
Quentin Willson
Nicolas Owen
Siobhan Hayes
Georgina Bouzova
Diarmud Gavin
Jan Ravens

Best celebs
Colin Jackson
Zoe Ball
Denise Lewis
Mark Ramprakash
Lesley Garrett
Jill Halfpenny
Aled Jones
Louisa Lytton
Darren Gough
Matt Dawson

[quote=footygirl]O.K, here's a poll for you. I'm trying to ascertain who was the best and worst celeb dancer in all series of SCD. I'm going to put forward 10 names in each catergorie and I'd like you to rank them in order, 1 being the lowest mark, 10 the highest. On Wednesday I'll tally the votes and knock out the lowest scoring in each catergorie.

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker - 7
Fiona Phillips - 4
Carol Vorderman - 2
David Dickinson - 3
Quentin Willson - 1 - worst of the worst
Nicolas Owen - 6
Siobhan Hayes - 4
Georgina Bouzova - 10 - best of the worst
Diarmud Gavin - 8
Jan Ravens - 9

Best celebs
Colin Jackson - 9 -
Zoe Ball - 6
Denise Lewis - 5
Mark Ramprakash - 10 - best of the best (no idea why i think that )
Lesley Garrett - 2
Jill Halfpenny - 7
Aled Jones - 1
Louisa Lytton - 8
Darren Gough - 4
Matt Dawson - 3

Worst celebs
Carol VOrerman 10 best
Gerogin Bouozza 9
Jan Ravens 8
Chris Parker 7
Dairmud Gavin 6
Siobhan Hayes 5
David Dickerson 4
Nicolas Owen 3
Quienton WIlson 2
Fiona Phillips 1

Best Celebs
Jill Halfpeeny 10
Mark Rampakash 9
Darren Gough 8
Colin Jackson 7
Louisa Lytton 6
Matt Dawson 5
Zoe BAll 4
Denis Lewis 3
Leysley GArrett 2
Aled Jones 1

Mel's scores:

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker 4
Fiona Phillips 2
Carol Vorderman 3
David Dickinson 8
Quentin Willson 1 (worst of the worst)
Nicolas Owen 5
Siobhan Hayes 6
Georgina Bouzova 10 (best of the worst)
Diarmud Gavin 7
Jan Ravens 9

Best celebs
Colin Jackson 9
Zoe Ball 3
Denise Lewis 2
Mark Ramprakash 10 (best of the best, surprise surprise)
Lesley Garrett 1 (worst of the best)
Jill Halfpenny 8
Aled Jones 4
Louisa Lytton 7
Darren Gough 5
Matt Dawson 6

You'll need an extra poll to appease the Billettes! Funniest celeb?
Last edited by Mel G : 09-02-2007 at 18:16

No doubt
Can I have your votes please

See above! For some reason they came out in a pink box as if I was quoting you, but I think I've sorted it out.

Given your location that's an appropriate choice of words
Thanks for your votes

Worst celebs
1/ Christopher Parker
2/ Fiona Phillips
3/ Siobhan Hayes
4/ David Dickinson
5/ Quentin Willson
6/ Diarmud Gavin
7/ Carol Vorderman
8/ Nicolas Owen
9/ Georgina Bouzova
10/ Jan Ravens

edit: oops i put one as the highest for this section
Best celebs
10/ Mark Ramprakash
9/ Jill Halfpenny
8/ Colin Jackson
7/ Matt Dawson
6/ Darren Gough
5/ Louisa Lytton
4/ Denise Lewis
3/ Zoe Ball
2/Lesley Garrett
1/ Aled Jones
Last edited by karenite_louise : 09-02-2007 at 18:31

Worst celebs
10/ Christopher Parker
1/ Fiona Phillips
5/ Siobhan Hayes
7/ David Dickinson
6/ Quentin Willson
4/ Diarmud Gavin
8/ Carol Vorderman
3/ Nicolas Owen
9/ Georgina Bouzova
2/ Jan Ravens


Best celebs
10/ Mark Ramprakash
8/ Jill Halfpenny If I have to see her **** jive once more, I'll put her on the worst list!
7/ Colin Jackson
6/ Matt Dawson
2/ Darren Gough
5/ Louisa Lytton
9/ Denise Lewis
3/ Zoe Ball
1/Lesley Garrett
4/ Aled Jones

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker= 2
Fiona Phillips =3
Carol Vorderman = 4
David Dickinson =5
Quentin Willson =1
Nicolas Owen =8
Siobhan Hayes = 6
Georgina Bouzova =10
Diarmud Gavin =7
Jan Ravens =9

Best celebs
Colin Jackson =9
Zoe Ball =8
Denise Lewis =3
Mark Ramprakash = 10 ( best celeb ever !!!)
Lesley Garrett =2
Jill Halfpenny =4
Aled Jones =1
Louisa Lytton =7
Darren Gough =6
Matt Dawson =5

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker 5
Fiona Phillips 10
Carol Vorderman 3
David Dickinson 4
Quentin Willson 9
Nicolas Owen 8
Siobhan Hayes 7
Georgina Bouzova 1
Diarmud Gavin 6
Jan Ravens 2

Best celebs
Colin Jackson 9
Zoe Ball 7
Denise Lewis 6
Mark Ramprakash 10
Lesley Garrett 3
Jill Halfpenny 8
Aled Jones 2
Louisa Lytton 5
Darren Gough 1
Matt Dawson 4
Last edited by dottysocks : 09-02-2007 at 22:09

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker= 2
Fiona Phillips =3
Carol Vorderman = 4
David Dickinson =5
Quentin Willson =1
Nicolas Owen =8
Siobhan Hayes = 6
Georgina Bouzova =10
Diarmud Gavin =7
Jan Ravens =9

Best celebs
Colin Jackson 9
Zoe Ball 7
Denise Lewis 6
Mark Ramprakash 10
Lesley Garrett 1
Jill Halfpenny 8
Aled Jones 2
Louisa Lytton 5
Darren Gough 3
Matt Dawson 4

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker 9
Fiona Phillips 10
Carol Vorderman 3
David Dickinson 4
Quentin Willson 8
Nicolas Owen 5
Siobhan Hayes 7
Georgina Bouzova 1
Diarmud Gavin 6
Jan Ravens 2

Best celebs
Colin Jackson 7
Zoe Ball 8
Denise Lewis 5
Mark Ramprakash 10
Lesley Garrett 4
Jill Halfpenny 9
Aled Jones 2
Louisa Lytton 6
Darren Gough 3
Matt Dawson 1

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker - 7
Fiona Phillips - 2
Carol Vorderman - 6
David Dickinson - 3
Quentin Willson - 1
Nicolas Owen - 4
Siobhan Hayes - 8
Georgina Bouzova - 9
Diarmud Gavin - 5
Jan Ravens - 10

Best celebs
Colin Jackson - 10
Zoe Ball - 8
Denise Lewis - 9
Mark Ramprakash - 6
Lesley Garrett - 2
Jill Halfpenny - 7
Aled Jones - 3
Louisa Lytton - 4
Darren Gough - 5
Matt Dawson - 1

Worst celebs:
Fiona Phillips-10
Christopher Parker-9
Quentin Willson-8
Diarmud Gavin-7
Nicolas Owen-6
David Dickinson-5
Siobhan Hayes-4
Carol Vorderman-3
Georgina Bouzova-2
Jan Ravens-1

Best celebs:
Mark Ramprakash-10
Zoe Ball-9
Jill Halfpenny-8
Denise Lewis-7
Colin Jackson-6
Louisa Lytton-5
Aled Jones-4
Darren Gough-3
Lesley Garrett-2
Matt Dawson-1

Just out of interest, how come there is no Natasha for best and no Denis Taylor for worst?

Worst celebs:
Fiona Phillips-10
Christopher Parker-9
Quentin Willson-8
Diarmud Gavin-7
Nicolas Owen-6
David Dickinson-5
Siobhan Hayes-4
Carol Vorderman-3
Georgina Bouzova-2
Jan Ravens-1

Best celebs:
Mark Ramprakash-10
Zoe Ball-9
Jill Halfpenny-8
Denise Lewis-7
Colin Jackson-6
Louisa Lytton-5
Aled Jones-4
Darren Gough-3
Lesley Garrett-2
Matt Dawson-1

Agree with Velvet_Fox!

Dippy we put the same! What are the chances of that? You obviously have exceptional taste!

Worst celebs
10 Georgina Bouzova
9 Carol Vorderman
8 Jan Ravens
7 Diarmud Gavin
6 Nicolas Owen
5 Siobhan Hayes
4 Christopher Parker
3 Fiona Phillips
2 David Dickinson
1 Quentin Willson


Best celebs
10 Mark Ramprakash
9 Colin Jackson
8 Denise Lewis
7 Louisa Lytton
6 Jill Halfpenny
5 Zoe Ball
4 Darren Gough
3 Matt Dawson
2 Aled Jones
1 Lesley Garrett

I see Emma is not on the list of best celebs. Very strange considering that the judges thought she's the best dancer in all 4 series. I'm not complaining though

Worst Celeb

10 Jan Ravens
9 Siobhan Hayes
8 Georgina Bouzova
7 David Dickinson
6 Gavin Diarmud
5 Nicholas Owen
4 Carol Vorderman
3 Christopher Parker
2 Fiona Phillips
1 Quentin Willson


Best Celebs

10 Mark Ramprakash ( the best in all the series!!!!)
9 Colin Jackson
8 Jill Halfpenny
7 Denise Lewis
6 Aled Jones
5 Zoe Ball
4 Darren Gough
3 Matt Dawson
2 Louisa Lytton
1 Lesley Garrett

awww my man not on either list - (shuffles back off to the sofa with steaming mug of tea to weep inconsolably)
I would have put him top - not necessarily as "best" or "worst" dancer but certainly one of the improvers and certainly top of the "fit" list
Last edited by Tango Trish : 10-02-2007 at 17:26

Worst celebs
10 Georgina Bouzova
9 Carol Vorderman
8 Jan Ravens
7 Diarmud Gavin
6 Nicolas Owen
5 Siobhan Hayes
4 Christopher Parker
3 Fiona Phillips
2 David Dickinson
1 Quentin Willson


Best celebs
10. Mark Ramprakash
9. Jill Halfpenny
8. Colin Jackson
7. Louisa Lytton
6. Denise Lewis
5. Zoe Ball
4. Matt Dawson
3. Darren Gough
2. Aled Jones
1. Lesley Garrett

Yes he should have been on the best list - he is quite dishy I liked him last year - but I do like Mark better!!!!

Worst celebs
10 Georgina Bouzova
9 Carol Vorderman
8 Jan Ravens
7 Siobhan Hayes
6 Diurmud Gavin
5 Fiona Phillips
4 David Dickinson
3 Nicholas Owen
2 Chris Parker
1 Quentin Willson


Best celebs
10. Jill Halfpenny
9. Zoe Ball
8. Colin Jackson
7. Denise Lewis
6. Louisa Lytton
5. Mark Ramprakash
4. Matt Dawson
3. Lesley Garrett
2. Matt Dawson
1. Aled Jones

I'm not sure how the worst celebs work. I've ranked giving 10 to the best of the worst. Also, surely Natasha and Emma should be in there, as there were both very good - one a winner and the other third, and were clearly better than at least 4 on the list, if not more.

Worst celebs
Christopher Parker - 6
Fiona Phillips - 3 (ENTERTAINMENT VALUE!)
Carol Vorderman - 1
David Dickinson - 2
Quentin Willson - 4
Nicolas Owen - 5
Siobhan Hayes - 7
Georgina Bouzova - 9
Diarmud Gavin - 10
Jan Ravens - 8

I was doing 1 as worst, 10 as best of the bunch!

Best celebs
Colin Jackson - 9 (loved him, but not the same charisma as Mark!)
Zoe Ball - 5
Denise Lewis - 8
Mark Ramprakash - 10 (best SCD celebrity ever!)
Lesley Garrett - 1
Jill Halfpenny - 6
Aled Jones - 2
Louisa Lytton - 7
Darren Gough - 4
Matt Dawson - 3

My choices were based on the Joy I felt on watching them dance, so v emotional (saying that Mark had spectacular technique!)