5.5

Methinks Clare can do no wrong .

I enjoyed that one - thought she did well

Clare can obviously skate but I didn't think it was all that to be honest. The actual routine itself wasn't that great and she's not quite as good at the dance part as some of the others are.
Last edited by claire2281 : 10-02-2007 at 19:18

When are Dunc and his hair on?

Why is there so much difference between the judges score? .

Are the pro skaters not allowed to speak?..... it's annoying me now, poor Andrei.

Now, if there's anyone I can't 'warm' to it's that damn Clare.
Last edited by waving not drow : 10-02-2007 at 19:20

I love Clare and Andrei but I thought that was their worst routine so far (although it was still really good) - she seems to be pushing herself a bit too far to include too many show-stoppers

Here comes the lovely Fred ...... and Kay.

I noticed that too . It's not fair - surely their opinion is equally as valid, if not more!

My favourite routine so far has been Emily and Daniel's. I don't think it will do Clare or Lisa any harm to have a slightly more lukewarm response this week.

Did anyone else notice there were no boos when Jason criticised Clare, when usually he only has to open his mouth to be drowned out? I hope it isn't an example of "Zoe Ball syndrome"
Last edited by tigerlilyxxxxx : 10-02-2007 at 19:21

Hands up every one who's just started thinking about Vincent Simone...

Love Fred and as a 40something have to back Kay

The Pro's should be allowed to speak just as much as the celeb's, he had to skate that routine, so Andrei should have been able to say whatever it was he was about to say. I wonder if when Extra starts to Pro's will actually be there as anything but to stand next to the celeb to remind people the celeb isn't actually out there on their own.

I did! I thought I was imagining it at first . I suppose it just goes to show that nobody's safe this week .

poor kay...a bit harsh from jason

My God - I think I'd rather be criticised for my skating than personal comments like Kay's just got .

Sheesh that was poor.


I am bored. Thats not good -SCD never bored me.

I think the problem is is that 4 of the females exude desperation to win (and boost their career) rather than learn a new skill and have some fun. Its okay to want to win - but do it for the challenge, not the chance of an OK exclusive, IACGMOOH, and a reality show on Living.

He did the same to kelly holmes last year calling her a man in drag

Aww - I like Kyran. He's a potential winner in my eyes .

What a bad attitude Kay had, though. She showed very bad grace.

That wasn't necessary. They are supposed to give them constructive criticisms that they can work on but he obviously just doesn't like her so what is she supposed to take away from that?

I remember that - that was awful! I'd be absolutely mortified if something like that was said to me .

Jason is too personal with his comments